The books of Chronicles : $b With maps, notes and introduction — John Shaqi
The books of Chronicles : $b With maps, notes and introductionElmslie, W. A. L. (William Alexander Leslie)
History
The books of Chronicles : $b With maps, notes and introduction
Elmslie, W. A. L. (William Alexander Leslie)
Bible. Chronicles -- Commentaries
new matter in Chronicles and escape the conclusion that it has all
been derived from the imagination of the Chronicler is to suppose that
for some time past it had been transmitted through the talk or writing
of Levites like-minded with the Chronicler and sharing the same
ecclesiastical fashion of speech; that, in fact, much of Chronicles was
built up by chroniclers before the Chronicler. There may be some truth
in this argument; for, as was said above, the Chronicler was surely not
the first Levite to feel the need for an “orthodox” history. The two
explanations can be regarded as supplementary rather than alternative;
but the present writer considers that stress should be laid chiefly
upon the first.
This investigation of the structure of Chronicles yields the following
general result. The position here taken is opposed to the theory that
the whole of the new material was the product of the Chronicler’s
imagination and literary skill. It leaves open the valuable possibility
that the new material may preserve historical facts and traditions
independent of those in Kings. On the other hand it admits that the
Chronicler has had an important share in shaping the material and that
(a) the consequent uniformity of style renders any attempt to analyse
the new matter into its proximate sources precarious (observe, however,
that the _immediate_ history of the sources behind the new material is
not of such primary importance to us as is the fundamental conclusion
that there _were_ such sources): and (b) whilst each part of the
new matter is entitled to a thorough examination on its merits,
great care must be exercised to determine exactly what part the
Chronicler has played. Thus it is probable that some features of
the narratives in Chronicles may _originate_ with the Chronicler:
that is only what we should expect from a man able to plan and carry
through a work so clearly intentioned and on such a large scale as
Chronicles‒Ezra‒Nehemiah. He may have told his tale not only in his own
words, but in his own way. We must be on our guard therefore to make
allowance for the strength of his convictions, for his conception of
the course of history and for the intentions with which he wrote. How
far these considerations affect the historical value of his work will
be dealt with below (§ 7).
This discussion of the sources may conclude by emphasising the
remarkable skill of the composition. The passages taken direct from
the earlier Scriptures have been so admirably combined with the new
material that the component parts have been wrought into a real unity.
It is evident we are dealing with an author of strong personality. What
the aim and purpose of this writer were we may now proceed to consider.
§ 6. THE PURPOSE AND METHOD OF THE CHRONICLER
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account