The Brass Check: A Study of American JournalismSinclair, Upton
General
The Brass Check: A Study of American Journalism
Sinclair, Upton
Associated Press; Journalism -- United States; Press -- United States
When the King of Greece was shot by an insane and irresponsible man,
the “New York Times” and hundreds of other papers ran the headline:
“KING OF GREECE ASSASSINATED BY A SOCIALIST.” And although it was
proven conclusively that the assassin hadn’t even heard of Socialism,
none of these papers saw fit to retract their lie.
When the great novelist, David Graham Phillips, was shot by one
Goldsborough, every paper in New York knew that Goldsborough not only
was not a Socialist, but had often spoken against Socialism. They also
knew that the latter had a personal grievance against the author.
Notwithstanding these facts, the “New York World” and other papers
came out with headlines: “DAVID GRAHAM PHILLIPS SHOT BY SOCIALIST.”
None of the papers retracted that lie.
When Theodore Roosevelt was shot at in Milwaukee, the Associated Press
sent broadcast the news that a Socialist had assaulted the Colonel.
Though it was proven by the evidence of the assailant’s own statement
that he was an affiliated member of a Democratic organization in New
York, that he had always voted the Democrat ticket, the “New York
Evening Telegram” ran the headline: “ROOSEVELT SHOT BY SOCIALIST.”
This the “Telegram” never retracted.
Perhaps the most tragic illustration of this kind of thing was the
“Chicago Anarchists.” There were one or two Anarchists among them; the
rest were Socialists, perfectly innocent working-class educators, who
were railroaded to the gallows by public hysteria, deliberately incited
by the newspapers of Chicago. Finley Peter Dunne, creator of “Mr.
Dooley,” was a reporter on one of these newspapers, and ten or twelve
years ago he narrated to me some of the things he had witnessed, the
most outrageous inventions deliberately cooked up. His voice trembled as
he told about it. I asked him why he did not write the story, and his
answer was that he had often tried to write it, but was blinded by his
own tears.
The same thing was done in the Debs railway strike of 1893. Every act of
violence that was committed was hailed by the newspapers of the country
as part of a terrorist campaign by the labor-unions. Therefore the
public permitted Grover Cleveland to smash this strike. Afterwards
Cleveland’s commission of investigation put the chief of police of
Chicago on the witness-stand, and heard him testify that the Railway
Managers’ Association had hired “thugs, thieves, and ex-convicts” as
their deputies, and that these men had set fire to freight-cars, and had
cut the hose of the Chicago firemen.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account