A few years ago, it was found desirable to compute some very accurate
logarithmic tables for the use of the great national survey of Ireland,
which was then, and still is in progress; and on that occasion a careful
comparison of various logarithmic tables was made. Six remarkable errors
were detected, which were found to be common to several apparently
independent sets of tables. This singular coincidence led to an
unusually extensive examination of the logarithmic tables published both
in England and in other countries; by which it appeared that thirteen
sets of tables, published in London between the years 1633 and 1822, all
agreed in these six errors. Upon extending the enquiry to foreign
tables, it appeared that two sets of tables published at Paris, one at
Gouda, one at Avignon, one at Berlin, and one at Florence, were infected
by exactly the same six errors. The only tables which were found free
from them were those of Vega, and the more recent impressions of Callet.
It happened that the Royal Society possessed a set of tables of
logarithms printed in the Chinese character, and on Chinese paper,
consisting of two volumes: these volumes contained no indication or
acknowledgment of being copied from any other work. They were examined;
and the result was the detection in them of the same six errors.[9]
[Footnote 9: Memoirs Ast. Soc. vol. III, p. 65.]
It is quite apparent that this remarkable coincidence of error must have
arisen from the various tables being copied successively one from
another. The earliest work in which they appeared was Vlacq's
Logarithms, (folio, Gouda, 1628); and from it, doubtless, those which
immediately succeeded it in point of time were copied; from which the
same errors were subsequently transcribed into all the other, including
the Chinese logarithms.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account