Schwalbe also explains the whole question of the reduction of the number of embryos. He says rightly that in _S. maculosa_, which gives birth to many young, there are in the oviduct many eggs which have only partly developed into embryos, and these, perhaps from want of room and nourishment, degenerate into the irregularly shaped whitish-yellow bodies which are occasionally found packed in between the developing embryos. Consequently all those eggs had been fertilised near the ovaries. _S. atra_ exhibits a further stage in so far as most of the eggs, fertilised above in the oviduct, degenerate, and only two or three become fully developed. These few embryos live on the degenerating eggs, which together produce the vitelline material spoken of above. The two full-grown and metamorphosed embryos, each measuring about 50 mm. in length, are equivalent to the numerous new-born larvae of _S. maculosa_, especially if the smaller size of the adult Alpine Salamander is taken into consideration. Mlle. von Chauvin[59] has experimented with the unborn larvae of this Salamander. She cut out 23 larvae and put them into water. One of them, already 43 mm. long, took earthworms on the next day, and the beautiful long, red gills became pale and shrunk, and on the third day were cast off close to the {121}body. New gills sprouted out on the same day, first in the shape of three tiny knobs on either side. After three weeks they had become round globes, which gradually sprouted out into several branches, far shorter and more clumsy than the original gills. During the whole time the larva was lying quietly at the bottom, in the darkest corner, but showed a good appetite. The fin of the tail disappeared and was supplanted by a stronger one. In the sixth week the skin was shed in flakes, and this process took fifteen days. This larva lived in the water for fourteen weeks and grew to 6 cm. in length! When the new gills gradually shrank, the compressed and finny tail assumed a round shape, the skin became darker and shinier, and after the larva had again shed its skin, there appeared the dark rugose skin of the typical _S. atra_. The gills were reduced to useless appendages–not cast off–and the creature crawled out of the water. A fortnight later the gill-clefts were closed. A second larva behaved similarly, first casting off the feathery gills, substituting a new and stronger set, which, however, fourteen days after excision from the uterus, shrank again, and on the nineteenth day the gill-clefts were closed. The lady also observed that nearly ripe larvae, when cut out, rushed about in the water and ate, just like the new-born larvae of the Spotted Salamander.