The Case Against Spirit PhotographsPatrick, C. Vincent
History
The Case Against Spirit Photographs
Patrick, C. Vincent
Parapsychology; Spirit photography; Spiritualism
2. If the sitter brings the right plates he will show the packet to the
medium before entering the dark-room to make sure that they are all
right. The medium takes the packet into his hand for a moment--turning
to the light to read the label--and passes them back with the remark
that they are the right kind--which now they certainly are, for the
sitter’s original packet is in the medium’s breast-pocket.
3. The sitter may perhaps autograph or otherwise mark his packet
before coming to the medium, in order to prevent any such substitution.
In this case the medium will wait until the wrapper is torn off in
the dark-room, when he may be able to handle the box for a moment on
some pretext,[4] and the dim light makes the substitution easier than
before, particularly as it occurs during the first minute or so in the
reduced light before the sitter’s eyes have become accustomed to it.
If these methods are employed, the medium usually finds it necessary
previously to mark the plate or plates in the box that have the latent
extras, in such a way that he may be sure of not getting the spirit
inverted: a slight scratch on one edge will suffice for this.
(_b_).--Methods involving substitution of the faked plate only, after
removal from the original packet:
1. With an unwary sitter this may be done in the dark-room. The sitter
usually marks the plates; while he is marking one, the medium may be
able to exchange his prepared plate for one of those not yet marked.
2. A trick dark-slide may be used, having a secret partition, and
already containing the faked plate.[5] If the sitter is content to mark
the plate after it is placed in the slide, he may easily be caused to
mark the prepared plate instead of his own.
3. If the plates are not marked, it will be a simple matter to
substitute, during the focussing operations, a duplicate slide
containing a faked plate.
4. Little accidents are apt to happen in the unaccustomed light of the
red lamp; while the sitter is groping on the floor for a wrapper he has
dropped, or while his attention is in some other way diverted for a
moment, the exchange is made.
I am aware that many will ridicule the idea of such a simple trick
being played upon an intelligent observer; but any conjuror, whose
business it is to do this kind of thing, knows that it is remarkably
easy.
5. Sometimes the first photographs taken are blanks, the sitter then
returns to the dark-room and loads up some fresh plates out of the
packet. It may not occur to him that an accomplice of the medium has
had access to the dark-room in the meantime, and when he gives this
account of the _séance_ a few days later he will probably have entirely
forgotten that the plates were not all loaded at once.
Substitution can, of course, be effected in many other ways; every
medium probably has his favourite method which he chiefly practises.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account