The Case Against Spirit PhotographsPatrick, C. Vincent
History
The Case Against Spirit Photographs
Patrick, C. Vincent
Parapsychology; Spirit photography; Spiritualism
I first suggested to four of them that we might try to obtain a spirit
photograph, like those described and reproduced in recent magazine
articles. They did not take me very seriously at first, but after
we had obtained the right atmosphere with a little table-turning,
they consented to try for a spirit photograph. When a spirit face
duly developed in addition to the sitter, everyone present expressed
amazement! I was naturally asked if I was “pulling their legs.” I
hedged and refused to say either yes or no, explaining that I wanted
the experiments to continue under scientific conditions. If, on the one
hand, I declared that I had not in any way faked the photograph, they
would probably believe me, and would not insist on further photographs
being taken under test conditions. If, on the other hand, I refused
to give such an assurance, they would think that I was probably
tricking them, and would take all possible steps to “bowl me out”;
and when they failed to do so would thereby establish evidence of
the genuineness of any further photographs we might be lucky enough
to obtain. After some little demur they saw the point of this--or as
much of it as I wished them to see--and agreed to meet again in my
room on the following Sunday evening, promising that I should be given
no opportunity of playing any tricks. It was also agreed that notes
should be taken during the _séances_ as far as possible, and that full
reports of what occurred should be drawn up afterwards by all of us in
conjunction, which everyone would sign.
I now quote their report on the next two meetings, omitting nothing
except their names, which I have replaced by single letters, at their
request.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account