The Case Against Spirit PhotographsPatrick, C. Vincent
History
The Case Against Spirit Photographs
Patrick, C. Vincent
Parapsychology; Spirit photography; Spiritualism
“The plate was developed by Patrick; A, C, and E watching. An extra
pair of eyes and the upper part of a nose developed, apparently on
the wall; they were brightly illuminated, from the same position as
the other figures. They were larger than those of the other members
of the group, and were over B’s head.
“We consider that this is a true account of what occurred. Barring
any very abstruse and elaborate explanation, it would seem that the
photograph is undoubtedly genuine.”
Then follow the signatures. As they made _me_ sign the report on this
meeting, I had to see that it was worded rather carefully, particularly
the last paragraph; the report _was_ true, so far as it went; and the
explanation of the result _was_ rather elaborate; so I felt I could
safely sign it.
I did not hold another photographic _séance_, but being emboldened by
success, introduced at the next meeting “a medium from London.” (As a
matter of fact he came from Trinity, but I had ascertained that nobody
knew him, which was the important thing.) After suitable preliminaries
we all sat round a large table in semi-darkness, holding hands. When
the medium had arranged “the balance of the circle” to his liking,
he proceeded to go into a trance, when queer things began to happen.
A candlestick was seen to slide along the mantelpiece and crash into
the coal-box, taking a framed photograph with it; sounds were heard
from a small cupboard; the window-curtains were parted; several people
saw spirit forms and eyes; and one was favoured with a spirit touch.
The medium’s Egyptian control, Nemetra, gave us wonderful accounts of
life in Memphis in the days of the Pharaohs--accounts which certainly
made up in picturesque detail for anything they lacked in historical
accuracy.
Unfortunately this meeting was not a complete success, as, immediately
the show was over, our ever-curious geologist E began hunting about the
floor, and discovered a small loop of fishing-line (being a post-war
fishing-line, the spirit forces had broken it). He could not very well
announce his find at the time, as the medium was not yet roused from
his trance, and the others were busy feeling his pulse, fanning him and
administering cold water!
By this time the results of the photographic _séances_ had become
pretty generally known, and the undesired notoriety brought so many
requests to allow other visitors at the _séances_ that it became
evident to me that the proceedings must terminate. So the next morning,
after seeing E, I told him and the others that the whole thing had been
a hoax, and that the photographs were frauds. I should like to add that
with one exception they took it extraordinarily well, particularly when
I explained what had been my object. They were still quite in the dark
about _how_ the photographs had been done, particularly when I told
them that there was no accomplice among them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account