The Case Against Spirit PhotographsPatrick, C. Vincent
History
The Case Against Spirit Photographs
Patrick, C. Vincent
Parapsychology; Spirit photography; Spiritualism
One need hardly point out that, although a medium who merely trusts
to luck will probably score a good proportion of “hits” by ringing
the changes on a few common types of face, he can greatly increase
this proportion by a little adroit “pumping” of the sitter which will
give him a guide to at least the general type of face expected, thus
enabling him to “deliver the goods,” at any rate approximately, at the
next _séance_.
It should also be remembered that in everyday life recognition is a
much more sketchy affair than might at first be suspected. Experiments
have shown that in reading, or in viewing a drawing, we do not take
cognizance of each individual element; on the contrary our attention
flits, so to speak, from point to point, skipping altogether the
intervening matter. We thus obtain an outline or skeleton impression
which we fill up from our own resources. We actually notice a few
salient features and interpolate the rest; hence, for example, the
well-known difficulty of “spotting” mis-prints in proofs. This process
is perfectly satisfactory for ordinary purposes such as reading, and
seldom results in our misinterpreting the symbols before us, and when
it does the context usually puts us right. But in dealing with spirit
photographs the context, if there can properly be said to be any, is
much more likely to put us wrong. The “salient features” which “leap to
the eyes” are, in this case, those which suffice to locate a face as
belonging to a certain general type, while the details which we fill up
for ourselves are just those which are necessary for the identification
of a particular individual. Consequently, false recognition is easy
provided the general type is all right. The “beauty” is emphatically
“in the eye of the beholder.” As “M.A. (Oxon),” a famous spiritualist
and a believer in spirit photographs, well said:
“Some people would recognise anything. A broom and a sheet are quite
enough to make up a grandmother for some wild enthusiasts who go with
the figure in their eye and see what they wish to see.... I have had
pictures that might be anything in this or any other world sent to
me, and gravely claimed as recognised portraits; palpable old women
authenticated as ‘my spirit brother, dead seventeen years, as he
would have been if he had ...’ etc.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account