The Catholic World, Vol. 10, October, 1869 to March, 1870Various
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 10, October, 1869 to March, 1870
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
"I object, of course, to the claim of miraculous
dispensation--certainly not to the doctrine of Christianity. This
claim impairs, to my mind, the soundness of him who makes it, and
indisposes us to his communion. This comes the wrong way; it comes
from without, not within. This positive, historical, authoritative
scheme is not consistent with our experience or our expectations.
It is something not in nature, it is contrary to that law of
nature which all wise men recognized, namely, never to require
a larger cause than is necessary to the effect. George Fox, the
Quaker, said that, though he read of Christ and God, he knew them
only from the like spirit in his own soul. We want all the aids to
our moral training. We cannot spare the vision nor the virtue of
the saints; but let it be by pure sympathy, not with any personal
or official claim. If you are childish and exhibit your saint as
a worker of wonders, a thaumaturgist, I am repelled. That claim
takes his teachings out of logic and out of nature, and permits
official and arbitrary senses to be grafted on the teachings. It
is the praise of our New Testament that its teachings go to the
honor and benefit of humanity--that no better lesson has been
taught or incarnated. Let it stand, beautiful and wholesome, with
whatever is most like it in the teaching and practice of men; but
do not attempt to elevate it out of humanity by saying, 'This was
not a man,' for then you confound it with the fables of every
popular religion; and my distrust of the story makes me distrust
the doctrine as soon as it differs from my own belief. Whoever
thinks a story gains by the prodigious, by adding something out
of nature, robs it more than he adds. It is no longer an example,
a model; no longer a heart-stirring hero, but an exhibition, a
wonder, an anomaly, removed out of the range of influence with
thoughtful men." (Pp. 42-44.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account