The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and ScienceVarious
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and Science
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
Now, we have the Bible without comment, but ministers, lawyers,
doctors, and business men are called in every Sunday, sometimes half
a dozen at one time, to give the comments, each according to his own
view. Every religious denomination was invited, but it does not appear
that any Catholic ever accepted the invitation; for, if he accepted, he
would leave his Catholicity outside until he finished his unsectarian
discourse. There may be something in common with all the sects which
sometimes may be called general Protestantism, though they profess to
call it unsectarianism; but one thing we know is common to them all,
and this something is opposition to Catholicity, and the dodge of
unsectarianism is adroitly invented in order to exclude Catholics from
enjoying equal rights with Protestants in matters relating to public
education and public charities. The state must let religion alone, and
unsectarians must desist from their disguised effort to unite church
and state in this country, while it has so strenuously opposed their
union in every Catholic country. They know that Catholics can take no
part in unsectarian teachings, but they would like us to do so, for in
proportion as we did so would we cease to be Catholics. The Catholic
view was so admirably expressed by the late Bishop Fitzpatrick, of
Boston, in his letter in the Eliot School difficulty, that we must give
it to our readers:
“I. Catholics cannot, under any circumstances, acknowledge, receive,
and use, as a complete collection and faithful version of the inspired
books which compose the written Word of God, the English Protestant
translation of the Bible. Still less can they so acknowledge, accept,
or use it, when its enforcement as such is coupled expressly with
the rejection of that version which their own church approves and
adopts as being correct and authentic; and yet this is required of
them by law. The law, as administered, holds forth the Protestant
version to the Catholic child, and says, ‘Receive this as the Bible.’
The Catholic child answers, ‘I cannot so receive it.’ The law, as
administered, says you must, or else you must be scourged and finally
banished from the school.
“II. The acceptance and recital of the Decalogue, under the form and
words in which Protestants clothe it, is offensive to the conscience
and belief of Catholics, inasmuch as that form and those words
are viewed by them, and have not unfrequently been used by their
adversaries, as a means of attack upon certain tenets and practices
which, under the teachings of the church, they hold as true and sacred.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account