The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and ScienceVarious
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and Science
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
unsectarianism, is an anti-Catholic principle. It proclaims the right
of man to determine all things in religion by his own private judgment,
and in this consists the distinctive feature of Protestantism.
We have thus shown that non-sectarianism, as a system of religious
teaching, is an impossibility. We now propose to show that in our
schools, asylums, reformatories, etc., it is in practice, as well as
in theory, an impossibility. We will show this, too, by Protestant and
unsectarian authority. At p. 264, vol. ii., _Providence Reform School
Investigation_, we read from the testimony of a Protestant Episcopal
trustee, who resigned on account, in part, of this impossibility:
“Q. Didn’t you know that no sectarian instruction was admitted inside
that institution? A. I don’t know what you call sectarianism. It is
pretty hard to say down in that school. We have had everything taught
and preached there. Q. Was not this an Episcopal book? A. It was a
book of devotions and prayers—a work by a divine of the English
Church. It was an Episcopal book. Q. Do you mean to say that a book of
Episcopal exercises is or is not a sectarian work? A. I am a member of
the Episcopal Church; we do not call ourselves a sect. Q. Didn’t you
know at the time you gave this book to the teacher that it was against
the rules of the school to have the doctrines of the true church given
out there, or of any church? A. I had never supposed it was against
the rules of that institution, and I should have been unwilling to
have sat for one hour as its trustee if I had supposed that I was
myself forbidden to pray, or to advise others to pray there, through
Jesus Christ, our Lord; and if the prayers I indicated, marked, and
numbered in that book are prayers forbidden in the Providence Reform
School or any other school, I have for the first time to learn what
is sectarianism. They are prayers which every Christian, whether he
belongs to any one of the various organizations of Christians in
this or any other country or not, would, I think, be willing to use
morning, noon, and night. Q. Didn’t you know that the by-laws place
religious instruction exclusively under the care of the superintendent
of the school” [who is a layman]?
The Hon. John C. Spencer, Secretary of State and Superintendent of
Schools in 1840, said in his report to the New York Legislature:
“There must be some degree of religious instruction, and there can be
_none_ without partaking more or less of a _sectarian character_. _The
objection itself proceeds from a sectarian principle_, and assumes the
power to control that which it is neither right nor practicable to
subject to any denomination. Religious doctrines of vital interest will
be inculcated.”
Another who has discussed this question of sectarianism with force and
great plainness of speech is the Rev. Dr. Spear, of Brooklyn, in the
columns of the _Independent_, thus:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account