In Deut. v., 15, the reason for keeping holy the sabbath day is different from the reason given in Ex. xx., 11. Both of these are given as the very words of Jahveh, spoken from “Horeb” or “Sinai.” One of the versions must be inaccurate, yet it is blasphemy to deny either. In Deut. v., 22, Moses says that after the ten commandments “he added no more.” In Exodus he added a large number of other commands (see xx.—xxiii.). We learn in Deut. viii., 4, that during the forty years wasted in the wilderness “thy raiment waxed not old upon thee.” This was very satisfactory for the adults, but what happened to the growing children? The raiment of a week-old baby can scarcely have been suitable to the man of forty; did the clothes grow with the body, and as the numbers of the people increased very much during the forty years, were new clothes born as well as new babies? If such questions are regarded as blasphemous, I can only answer that they are suggested by Moses’ assertion of the remarkable durability of the raiment, and raiment that did not become old might surely also grow and reproduce itself. Once begin miracle-working on old clothes, and none can say how far it may go. It is blasphemy to assert that it is wrong to swear, for the Bible commands: “Thou shalt fear the Lord thy God.... and swear by his name” (Deut. x., 20). It is blasphemy to assert that it is right to swear, for the Bible commands: “Swear not at all” (Matt, v., 34). Deuteronomy xiii., from the first verse to the last, is a disgrace to the book in which it is contained, and a scandal to the community which permits it to be circulated as of divine authority. Yet it is blasphemy to attack it and to show its horrible atrocity. If a prophet or dreamer arise and try to turn away the Hebrews from Jahveh, then they are told: “The Lord your God proveth you, to know whether ye love the Lord your God” (v. 3). Yet, although it is Jahveh’s own doing, that unfortunate “prophet, or that dreamer of dreams, shall be put to death” (v. 5). The same fate is to befall “thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which is as thine own soul” (v. 6), if such try to turn any away from Jahveh’s worship; with a refinement of cruelty, devilish in its wickedness, “thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death” (v. 9). The wife, passionately loved, is to see her husband, in whose bosom she has lain, raise his hand against her, foremost of a howling mob, greedy for her blood. The daughter is to clasp her father’s knees in vain; he must strike her down as she clings to him in her agony. The trusting and trusted friend is to be betrayed to the slaughterers, and the hand most closely grasped in love is to be the first to catch up the heavy stone and to beat out the faithful life. And it is blasphemy to cry out against this horror, but not blasphemy to ascribe its invention to the god “whose tender mercy is over all his works.”