The Church, the Falling Away, and the RestorationShepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Religion
The Church, the Falling Away, and the Restoration
Shepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Churches of Christ -- Doctrines; Disciples of Christ -- Controversial literature; Disciples of Christ -- Doctrines
without a voice from heaven or a special visit from some angel or
spirit. If you have anything worse, for my part I wish to hear it.”
The cry was, “Let us hear something more.” On turning to and fro, I
read an article on “Modern Missionaries.” This, with the “Capital
Mistake of Modern Missionaries,” finished my reading for the evening.
On closing this essay, Elder Vardeman said: I am not so great a
missionary man as to fall out with you on that subject. I must hear
more before I condemn or approve.” I then distributed my ten copies
among the ten most distinguished and advanced elders in the room,
requesting them to read these numbers during the recess of the debate,
and to communicate freely to me their objections. We separated. So the
matter ended at that time. (“Memoirs of A. Campbell,” Vol. II, page
88.)
At the close of the debate the Baptist preachers were so much pleased
with the results, and so tolerant of what they found in the “Christian
Baptist,” that they requested Mr. Campbell to furnish them with the
printed proposals for its publication, in order to extend its
circulation, and urged him to make an immediate tour through the State.
Previous engagements prevented, and he could only comply with their
wishes so far as to visit Bryan’s Station, Mayslick, and Lexington;
promising, if possible, to make a more extended tour through the State
the following year.
As Mr. McCalla’s character for ability was well established and equally
well sustained by his Presbyterian brethren, the results of the
discussion were less damaging to his reputation than to the cause which
he advocated, which to this day has never recovered from the withering
defeat which it then suffered. But Mr. McCalla labored for some time
after the debate to change public sentiment by preaching on the subjects
discussed in various parts of Kentucky, endeavoring at the same time to
prejudice the minds of the people in advance against the report of the
debate which Mr. Campbell was soon to publish.
Mr. Campbell was fully satisfied with his part in the discussion, and
was now thoroughly satisfied that debates were a great means of reaching
the people with the truth, for he wrote:
Public discussion, is, we are convinced, one of the best means of
propagating the truth and of exposing error in doctrine or practice.
We now reap the benefits of public debates of former times, and we
have witnessed the beneficial results of those in our own time. And we
are fully persuaded that a week’s debating is worth a year’s
preaching, such as we generally have, for the purpose of disseminating
truth and putting error out of countenance. There is nothing like
meeting face to face in the presence of many witnesses and “talking
the matter over”; and the man that can not govern his spirit in the
midst of opposition and contradiction is a poor Christian indeed.
(Christian Baptist, Vol. 1, page 189.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account