The Church, the Falling Away, and the RestorationShepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Religion
The Church, the Falling Away, and the Restoration
Shepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Churches of Christ -- Doctrines; Disciples of Christ -- Controversial literature; Disciples of Christ -- Doctrines
Our argument from this topic is, that baptism being ordained to be to
a believer a formal and personal remission of all his sins, can not be
administered unto an infant without the gravest perversion and abuse
of the nature and import of this ordinance. Indeed, why should an
infant that never sinned—that, as Calvinists say, is guilty only of
“original sin,” which is a unit—be baptized for the remission of sins?
(“Campbell-McCalla Debate,” pages 116, 117, 136.)
For a number of years prior to the debate Mr. McCalla had taken great
delight in assailing the distinctive tenets of the Baptists, and gave
them no little annoyance. As the debate progressed his defeat became
more and more manifest and raised Mr. Campbell to great popularity among
them; but as it was not his intention to seek popularity among them by
catering to their admiration, by fostering their favorite but defective
views of the Gospel and its institutions, he deemed it wise on the
evening of the fifth day of the debate to candidly inform the principal
Baptist preachers present of the exact position which he occupied. Being
assembled in a room where he had called them together, he introduced
himself fully to their acquaintance in the following manner, as related
by himself:
“Brethren, I fear that if you knew me better you would esteem and love
me less. For let me tell you that I have almost as much against you
Baptists as I have against the Presbyterians. They err in one thing
and you in another; and you are each nearly equidistant from original
apostolic Christianity.” I paused; and such a silence as ensued,
accompanied by a piercing look from all sides of the room, I seldom
before witnessed. Elder Vardeman at length broke the silence by
saying: “Well, sir, we want to know our errors or your heterodoxy. Do
let us hear it. Keep nothing back.” I replied: “I know not where to
begin; nor am I in health and vigor after the toils of the day to
undertake so heavy a task; but I am commencing a publication called
The Christian Baptist, to be devoted to all such matters, a few copies
of which are in my portmanteau, and, with your permission, I will read
you a few specimens of my heterodoxy.” They all said: “Let us hear—let
us hear the worst error you have against us.” I went upstairs and
unwrapped the first three numbers of the Christian Baptist that ever
saw the light in Kentucky. I had just ten copies of the first three
numbers. I carried them into the parlor and read a sample, the first
essay on the clergy—so much of it as respected the “call to the
ministry” as then taught in the “kingdom of the clergy,” and
especially among the Baptists. This was the first essay ever read from
it in Kentucky. After a sigh and a long silence, Elder Vardeman said:
“Is that your worst error, your chief heterodoxy? I do not care so
much about that, as you admit that we have a providential call,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account