"Ought to be carefully studied by preachers."--Christian World. "Is well worth reading by all who have to do with unbelief."--Methodist Times. "It is a frank and full inquiry into the grounds of modern unbelief, and a masterly plea for candour in Christian thought."--Christian Advocate. "Calmly-reasoned criticism.... Writes in excellent style."--Clarion. "Mr. Vivian's book is an admirable reply to When it Was Dark."--New Age. "An interesting and instructive book."--Positivist Review. "This book does much to show where rationalism can rightly influence both our creed and our conduct."--Light (devoted to the interests of psychical research). "I am recommending it to everybody who is interested in the religious problems of the hour."--The Reader. "Comprehensive in scope, judiciously written, and embodying an admirable selection of facts."--Literary Guide. "The book is written with marked ability."--Teacher. "Philip Vivian is a clear thinker, who has made a special study both of Christian evidences and of comparative religions."--Journal of Education. "Comprehensive, systematic, and strenuous ... based on much knowledge ... very capable."--Educational Times. "Exhaustive ... up-to-date ... claims the respect of thinking people, and demands the prayerful attention of all Christian teachers."--Bombay Gazette. "Any earnest, thoughtful man may read the volume with considerable profit."--Daily Mail, Brisbane. "Thoughtful and evidently earnest work."--Herald, Melbourne. "Clear, forceful, fair, and temperate."--Register, Adelaide. "Well arranged and well written, and adding to-day's conclusions to the polemics of the past."--Bulletin, Sydney. "A reliable and useful guide."--Otago Times, New Zealand. "A healthy tonic for parsons and Churches."--Cape Times. "A very stirring book."--Star, Johannesburg. "Many of its chapters are of great interest."--African Monthly. "Mr. Vivian has brought to his task wide reading and a clear, judicial mind; nor has he feared to follow his investigation to a logical end."--World, Toronto. "A clever and frank writer."--World, Vancouver. "From first to last most interesting and instructive."--Japan Chronicle. "It contains in little space a summary of modern knowledge."--Chicago Daily News. "A work of unusual clearness, dealing with the entire question of the so-called conflict between religion and science."--American Review of Reviews. "Will appeal to the widest possible range of readers."--New York Herald. NOTES [1] In the June (1906) number of Review of Theology and Philosophy, edited by Professor Allan Menzies, D.D. [2] As the Rev. John A. Hutton attempts to show in the Hibbert Journal, July, 1905. [3] In his address at the London Diocesan Conference in April, 1904. [4] When addressing a conference of clergy and church-workers at Blandford on September 7th, 1905.