The City of the Mormons; or, Three Days at Nauvoo, in 1842Caswall, Henry
History
The City of the Mormons; or, Three Days at Nauvoo, in 1842
Caswall, Henry
Latter Day Saints -- Illinois; Nauvoo (Ill.)
"The Church of England," said he,
"reminds me of a story I heard about an old cow--" As he was becoming
abusive I thought it best to check him, and seriously requested him to
inform me whether it was an English cow or an Irish bull of which he was
speaking. At this the younger Mormons began to laugh, and Paddy seemed
rather disconcerted and was silent.
An old American in a blue home-spun suit, and with a disagreeable
expression in his face, now entered the lists against me. He told me
that I was in great darkness and unbelief, and that I ought to repent,
obey the gospel, and be baptized. I replied, that as for repentance, I
repented every day; as for obedience, without boasting, I might claim to
be equal to the "Latter-day Saints;" and as for baptism, I had been
lawfully baptized by one having authority. He said that Church of
England baptism possessed only the authority derived from Acts of
Parliament, and that the English Church was merely a Parliament Church.
I replied, that the English Church had a double sanction: first, that of
Christ--who founded the Catholic Church, of which the English Church is
a portion; and secondly, that of Parliament, by which, long after its
foundation, it was acknowledged as the National Religion. "As for you
Mormons," I said, "it is now my turn to say something about your
religion, since you have spoken freely of mine. It is easy for you to
argue as you do about the descent of the Indians from Israel, the
probability of the restoration of miraculous powers to the Church, and
the errors and inconsistencies of existing sects; but in regard to the
real question at issue, on which your religion depends, namely, the
inspiration of your prophet, you have given me no satisfaction
whatever." They requested me to state what evidence I should consider
satisfactory. I replied, "When the Jewish dispensation was to be
introduced, God enabled Moses to work great wonders with his rod. God
smote a mighty nation with miraculous plagues. He divided the Red Sea
and the River Jordan. He came down on Mount Sinai amid clouds and
lightnings and the terrific sound of the trumpet of heaven. He caused
Moses to strike the rock and the waters gushed forth. He rained down
manna for the space of forty years in the wilderness. Again, when the
Christian dispensation was to be established, Christ walked upon the
waters; He controlled the winds and the waves; He fed assembled
thousands with a few loaves and fishes; He healed the sick; He opened
the eyes of the blind; He brought the dead to life; and finally, He
raised Himself from the grave.
"You maintain that your prophet is sent to establish a third
dispensation. I demand, therefore, what signs are given to prove his
commission?"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account