The Clergyman's Hand-book of Law: The Law of Church and GraveScanlan, Charles Martin
Religion
The Clergyman's Hand-book of Law: The Law of Church and Grave
Scanlan, Charles Martin
Burial laws -- United States; Ecclesiastical law -- United States
*462.* _Crime, Fraud, Exhume, Autopsy._—In an action on an insurance
policy where there is evidence of fraud, as death by poison, a court may
order a body exhumed for examination, although the person having the right
to control the burial of the body is not a party to the suit.(814) Public
officials have the right to disinter a body to ascertain whether a crime
has been committed.(815) But without a coroner’s inquest or consent of the
surviving consort or next of kin, a doctor has no right to perform an
autopsy.(816)
*463.* _Tort, Corpse._—The general rule is that an action of tort may be
maintained by the widow or next of kin for the mutilation of a corpse or
even for negligently exposing it to the elements.(817) In a few cases the
right has been denied.(818)
*464.* _Custodian, Burial, Mutilation._—In the absence of a widow, a son
is the lawful custodian of the body of his deceased father for
preservation, representation, and burial, and may maintain an action for
unlawful mutilation thereof. The sense of outrage and mental suffering
resulting directly from the wilful mutilation of the body of a parent, is
a proper independent element of compensatory damages.(819)
*465.* _Property in a Corpse, Mummy, Executors._—The question of property
in a corpse has been generally denied. However, in case of a mummy which
has become an object of curiosity, the case may be different. Where a
testator ordered his body burned and the executor presented a bill for
£321 for doing so, the court disallowed it on the ground that when a man
is dead his next of kin or executors have the right to dispose of his
body; but that as it is not property, a man has no right to bequeath it
for a particular purpose.(820) Also, where a man was in jail and died
during his imprisonment and the jailer refused to give up the body until
the debt was paid, the court held that there was no property in the
corpse, and therefore there could be no lien upon it and he must surrender
it.(821)
*466.* _Rights, Duties, Body, Will._—While there is no property in a dead
body so that it may be sold, there are rights and duties out of which may
arise tort and criminal actions. The question of the right of a man to
dispose of his body by will is not well settled in this country.(822)
There are many cases that hold that a person has the right to make a
binding testamentary disposition of his own body after death.(823) But on
the contrary it has been held that one can not by his will confer any
right as to the disposition of his body.(824)
*467.* _Monument, Fence._—Giving the right to bury in one’s cemetery lot
carries with it the right to erect a monument; but it does not carry with
it the right to fence the cemetery lot or interfere with other graves
therein. Therefore, the monument must be of such size and so located and
erected as not to interfere with the rights of others.(825)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account