The collected works of William Hazlitt, Vol. 11 (of 12)Hazlitt, William
Philosophy
The collected works of William Hazlitt, Vol. 11 (of 12)
Hazlitt, William
English essays -- 19th century
at least much better than the pompous nonentities to which we are
accustomed. There is very little of passion or emotion given or
attempted, but we think the expression of attention in the surrounding
audience is varied very happily, and with great truth of nature. The
most picturesque and interesting part of the picture is the groupe in
which a girl with a back-figure is supporting (we suppose) the mother of
_Lucretia_. The expression of the countenance in the latter reminded us
of Annibal Caracci, and we are always glad to be reminded of him.
Certainly the same effect was not produced upon our minds by the boy in
the foreground, with sandy hair and weak eyes, who is crying so
piteously: still less did we like the figure of a man in the right hand
corner, who is explaining the story to another with his fists clenched,
and in a boxing attitude. The model for a Roman warrior is as little to
be sought in a Fives Court, as of a Roman patriot in a debating society,
or even (with leave be it spoken) in an English House of Commons. We
have dwelt the longer on this picture, because its immediate effect on
the eye is by no means in proportion to its real merit. The
drab-coloured quakerism of the tone conceals it from observation almost
as much as if it had a veil over it. We do not really understand the
object of these sickly half-tints, which all French artists, and some of
our own, affect. Nicolas Poussin, who had no relief of light and shade,
had strong contrasts of colour: or even if he had had neither, the great
distinctness of his outline, and his striking manner of telling the
story, might still have formed a sufficient excuse for him. In short,
the style of colouring adopted in this picture may, for aught we know,
accord very well with some more artificial and recondite style of
historical composition; but we are sure, it has nothing to do with
natural expression, or immediate effect.
It has been said, that ‘a great book is a great evil.’ We think the same
thing might be applied to pictures: or at least we should not instance
the large picture in this collection of _The Burial of our Lord_, by C.
Coventry, as an exception to the rule. We admit, however, that the face,
dress, and figure of the old man holding the drapery over Christ, are
picturesque, and in the fine manner of Rembrandt. The attitude and
action of this figure are exactly the same as those of a similar figure
in Mr. Bird’s picture of the same subject. This is rather a singular
coincidence in two pictures exhibited at the same time, and which it is
therefore improbable to suppose could have been copied one from the
other. The other figures about Christ we cannot bring ourselves to
admire: they resemble painted wood. The colour of the Christ is a livid
purple, the worst of all possible colours. The women are better; though
the fine turn in the waist of one of them is not in the best style of
history, which does not profess to exhibit women of fashion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account