“It is affirmed by Cicero, in his oration for Flaccus, that the
commonwealths of Greece were all shaken or ruined by the intemperance of
their Comitia, or assemblies of the people. The truth is, if good heed
in this point be not taken, a commonwealth will have bad legs. But all
the world knows he should have excepted Lacedaemon, where the people, as
has been shown by the oracle, had no power at all of debate, nor (till
after Lysander, whose avarice opened a gulf that was not long ere it
swallowed up his country) came it ever to be exercised by them. Whence
that commonwealth stood longest and firmest of any other but this,
in our days, of Venice; which, having underlaid herself with the like
institution, owes a great, if not the greater, part of her steadiness to
the same principle; the great Council, which is with her the people, by
the authority of my Lord Epimonus, never speaking a word. Nor shall any
commonwealth, where the people in their political capacity is talkative,
ever see half the days of one of these, but, being carried away by
vainglorious men (that, as Overbury says, void more than they drink),
swim down the stream, as did Athens, the most prating of these dames,
when that same ranting fellow Alcibiades fell a-demagoguing for the
Silician War.
“But whereas debate, by the authority and experience of Lacedaemon
and Venice, is not to be committed to the people in a well-ordered
government, it may be said that the order specified is but a slight
bar in a matter of like danger; for so much as an oath, if there be no
recourse upon the breach of it, is a weak tie for such hands as have
the sword in them, wherefore what should hinder the people of Oceana,
if they happen not to regard an oath from assuming debate, and making
themselves as much an anarchy as those of Athens? To which I answer,
Take the common sort in a private capacity, and, except they be injured,
you shall find them to have a bashfulness in the presence of the better
sort, or wiser men, acknowledging their abilities by attention, and
accounting it no mean honor to receive respect from them; but if they be
injured by them, they hate them, and the more for being wise or great,
because that makes it the greater injury. Nor refrain they in this
case from any kind of intemperance of speech, if of action. It is no
otherwise with a people in their political capacity; you shall never
find that they have assumed debate for itself, but for something else.
Wherefore in Lacedaemon where there was, and in Venice where there is,
nothing else for which they should assume it, they have never shown so
much as an inclination to it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account