The constitution violated : $b An essay — John Shaqi
The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
made of power;[64] and if this should ever unfortunately happen to be
our case, our Parliaments will neither be willing nor able to check the
abuse of any power, or to punish the offenders. For this reason, we
ought to be extremely jealous of loading our people with pains and
penalties, and subjecting them to a multitude of penal laws; for
oppression may be easily cloaked under an Act of Parliament, and many
may be punished, under pretence of their having been guilty of some
action made penal by Statute without raising any general murmur among
the people, or giving alarm to those who think _themselves_ in no danger
from any such prosecution. Whereas the least act of oppression without
the pretence of Parliament would raise a general murmur and an universal
alarm, because every man in the kingdom would then think himself in
danger. In this nation no man of common sense would extend his power of
oppression to any great length till he had got a Parliament to his mind;
but when he has got such a Parliament, his power will then be without
control, and by subjecting multitudes of our people to high pains and
penalties, and the danger of being prosecuted upon penal Statute, we may
render it easy for a man to accomplish this end, which, when once
accomplished, may be by the same methods easily preserved as long as he
pleases.
“No law can be proposed, my Lords, for the necessity of which some
reasons may not be urged; even the most tyrannical laws have been made
under the pretence of preventing some real abuse.[65] But all wise
nations have chosen to allow an abuse to escape unpunished rather than
to make such a law as might possibly involve the innocent in the same
punishment with the guilty.
“If ever any such custom or law should come to be established in this
kingdom, the happiness and security of our people would be at an end; we
might expect sometime or other to have informers as numerous and
frequent in our streets, and in all public places, as ever the
‘delatores’ or informers were about Rome under their most tyrannical
emperors.
“I shall grant that if the justice of peace understands the spirit of
our laws, and acts justly, he will examine the informer narrowly as to
circumstances, and will not commit unless the informer gives good
reasons against those he informs against. But the words of this clause
make no such precautions necessary. We are not now to inquire what the
justice _ought_ to do, but what he _may_ do, and I _will_ say that by
these words, an information on oath will be a sufficient authority for
the commitment, and will excuse the justice from all the penalties of
false imprisonment.
“May we not suppose that such informations may be cooked up, and persons
of great credit committed?... Can we say that any subject is safe who
_may_ upon malicious information which he cannot disprove be brought
into such danger? I say, my Lords, on information which he cannot
disprove, for this will always be the case.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account