The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
call upon your Lordships, and the united powers of the State, to examine
it thoroughly and decisively, and to stamp upon it the indelible stigma
of the public abhorrence. And I again implore those holy prelates of our
religion to do away with these iniquities from among us. Let them
perform a lustration! Let them purify this House, and this country, from
this sin!”
But alas! among the hereditary counsellors, the bishops too sit silent
and unmoved when those Acts of 1866 and 1869 were passed, which shook
the bulwarks of our constitution, and which, pronouncing _that_ to be a
necessity which God has pronounced to be deadly sin, exalted its
practice henceforth into an acknowledged and regulated traffic!
CHAPTER V.
The offences which are punished under other Acts of Parliament, or
according to the common law of England, are all either carefully defined
by these Acts and that law, or else they are such as unmistakably to
define themselves. In these Contagious Diseases Acts, on the contrary,
there is no definition of the offence treated under them, nor do we find
that the offence is such as unmistakably to define itself. On the
contrary, we find amongst the advocates of these Acts, no less than in
society generally, the widest possible variety of opinion as to the
definition of a prostitute. This variety of opinion is only indicative
of the immense difficulty of drawing any marked line as to where a woman
may be justly designated by this name. There are many easy-going persons
of the upper classes who know nothing of the poor, and who talk of this
unhappy class as if they were as easily distinguishable as a negro is
from a white man; but those who are acquainted with the poorer classes
of women know the utter fallacy of this method of judgment, and are well
aware that there is amongst this class of sinners as long and varied a
series as in any other. Moreover, those who have looked at all carefully
into the subject observe, that there are in human nature deeply-seated
causes why this indistinctness of definition is maintained rather than
otherwise; for they can scarcely help being conscious that the real
cause of the difficulty which men who legislate on this subject
experience in arriving at a just determination of that degree of guilt
which is to attach this terrible appellation to a woman, arises in a
great measure from the disingenuousness of men, and their disinclination
that their sex should be acknowledged as the accomplices and companions
of the persons thus defined. Until war be waged against impure men, as
well as against impure women, it will remain impossible to define
prostitution. It is amazing to see in this unequal war waged against the
weaker sex only, how men who legislate for their own interests have, as
it were, talked themselves into the notion, if it were possible to do
so, that these poor women are sinners in this respect in their own
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account