The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
These general statements will commend themselves to the minds of most
English readers. Let them then be fully awake to the dangers which are
now undermining these cherished advantages of the system under which we
have, up till this time, lived. It is strange that while a strong stand
is being made at present for the freer exercise of local
self-government, and a practical step in that direction has been taken
in the extension of the municipal franchise, a step, and a most fatal
step, has been taken in the opposite direction by the Government through
the Acts which we condemn; and we have already had exhibited to us as
its fruits a sight unwonted in England—the sight of an energetic
Corporation completely set aside and overruled within the limits of its
own jurisdiction by the creatures of imperial tyranny, the very lowest
of the executive. This is the first-fruits in England of the great and
fatal effort at centralization begun by these Acts.
Are the people of England willing, not only that personal liberty should
be interfered with, but that corporate freedom should be threatened with
annihilation by these Acts of Parliament, which unless repealed will no
doubt be followed by others equally aggressive in principle, against
which we shall then have no argument,—a result which will, as we may
learn from the words which we have just quoted, be little less than the
destruction of the stability of English political life?
And this centralization, which is so much to be deprecated, is
introduced by these Acts with those very concomitants which render its
effect most ruinous, namely, the establishment of a system of police
espionage, a thing utterly foreign and abhorrent to all the instincts
and convictions of Englishmen. On the subject of that constant and
minute police interference which these laws have introduced so
extensively into England, I may quote the weighty words of Lieber.
“It is necessary,” says he, in his _Political Ethics_, “to have seen
nations who have been forced for centuries to submit to constant and
minute police interference, in order to have any conception of the
degree to which manly action, self-dependence, resoluteness, and
inventiveness of proper means can be eradicated from a whole community.
On this account systematic interference weakens governments instead of
strengthening them; for in times of danger, when popular energy is
necessary, when every man must do his duty, or the State is lost, men
having forgotten how to act, look listlessly to the Government, not to
themselves. The victories of Napoleon over the many States east and
south of France were in a great measure owing to this natural course of
things.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account