The Courtship of AnimalsPycraft, W. P. (William Plane)
Science
The Courtship of Animals
Pycraft, W. P. (William Plane)
Animal behavior; Natural selection
The facts which have come to light in regard to the “Courtship” of
Butterflies since Darwin wrote are meagre enough, but such as have been
recorded give no support to the supposition that the females are really
influenced by, or even perceive the colours of, their mates. Just on
five-and-twenty years ago the naturalist Skertchly published some
observations on the Courtship of that magnificent Bornean Butterfly
_Ornithoptera brookiana_. He one day came on a male sipping honey from
the flowers of a tree, vibrating its wings with the rapidity of a
Hawk-moth, and the vivid green of the wings flashing in the sunlight,
though the crimson areas thereof were invisible. The female came “and
did all the wooing.” They circled about in flight with the female
above and somewhat behind, so that she could see, we are told, the
emerald markings; but there was no real evidence here that she was
really influenced by his coloration, and if this really were the case
then the coloration of the female equally demands an explanation,
for this, though less gorgeous than that of the male, is far from a
primitive type; on the contrary, it is of a highly differentiated
character. Furthermore, in this genus, as has already been remarked,
the males outnumber the females by, roughly, one hundred to one. Again,
Moseley, the naturalist on the Memorable Voyage of the Challenger in
1872, when in the Aru Islands, was once “lucky enough to find a flock
of about a dozen males fluttering round and mobbing a single female.
They were then hovering slowly, quite close to the ground, and were
easily caught.” But he was by no means convinced that any choice was
exerted. And he suggests “a series of experiments, in which, in the
case of highly-coloured and decorated Butterflies, the colours should
be rubbed off the wings of a few among a number of males, or painted
over of a black or brown colour. It might be tested whether the females
would always prefer the highly-coloured ones.” Such experiments are
foredoomed to failure, for the removal of the scales would remove the
only source of communication between the sexes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account