World War, 1914-1918 -- Campaigns -- Turkey -- Gallipoli Peninsula
So the episode of the Dardanelles Expedition, equal in splendour of
conception, heroism, and tragedy, came to an end. During the eight and
a half months of its continuance upon the Peninsula itself, the land
forces, including the Royal Naval Division, but not counting the Navy
or the French (whose losses are not published), suffered the following
loss:
+--------------------+---------+---------+----------+
| Killed. | Wounded.| Missing.| Total. |
+--------------------+---------+---------+----------+
|Officers 1,745 | 3,143 | 353 | 5,241 |
|Other ranks 26,455 | 74,952 | 10,901 | 112,308 |
| ------ | ------ | ------ | ------- |
| Totals 28,200 | 78,095 | 11,254 | 117,549 |
+--------------------+---------+---------+----------+
A large proportion of the missing must be counted as killed. The number
of sick admitted to hospital between April 25 and December 11, 1915,
was 96,683, of whom also a considerable proportion died. If we may take
about one-quarter of the missing as killed, and about one-twentieth
of the sick as having died, the total of lives lost amounts to about
36,000. The total losses of the Turks have been variously estimated
between 400,000 and 500,000, but those estimates are conjectural.
[Sidenote: MILITARY CAUSES OF THE FAILURE]
The causes of our failure have been, as I hope, reasonably signified
in the preceding account of the campaign. They may be summarised in
relation either to the movements on the spot, or to the attitude of the
home Government. On the spot, we failed chiefly owing to the premature
naval attacks, which gave the enemy warning of our intention, and owing
to the design of forcing the Straits with the Navy alone, which might
indeed have been temporarily successful if persisted in, but in the end
would have given us only a dubious advantage; for a fleet penetrating
to the Sea of Marmora would have remained dangerously isolated so
long as both sides of the Straits were strongly held by the enemy.
The second initial error was the delay in concentrating the military
forces for the land attack--a delay chiefly due to the retention of
the 29th Division in England, and to the necessity of returning the
transports from Mudros to Alexandria for the rearrangement of the
military stores and munitions. As to the actual operations on land, it
might be argued, in the light of wisdom after the event, that the first
landing had better have been made by a combined force at Suvla Bay
and on the Ocean Beach at Anzac, though, in that case, larger numbers
than those allotted to the Expedition at the beginning must have been
demanded. Again, with regard to the failure of the August operations,
it might now be maintained that the forces at Anzac were dissipated
by the assaults at Lone Pine and the Nek, and by the over-elaborate
subdivision of the attacking forces upon our left. Even in spite of
the natural intricacy of the ground, a concentration of all available
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account