At that moment Alice was called and went away. Poor, poor papa! he was wrong; but how my heart entered into his sufferings. I did not think of the bitterness of love disbelieved and disturbed, of my mother's silent martyrdom--I thought only of my father, my first of men! He loved her, and he thought she _pitied_ him. I started from my seat at the touch of this intolerable thought. I realized in the most overwhelming fulness, what he meant when he said, "Pity is a cheat!" Pity! it was dreadful to think of it--though it was but a mistake, a fancy--what a terrible cloud it was! I will not say that this story filled my mind so much, that I do not recollect the other events of that day; on the contrary, I recollect them perfectly, down to the most minute detail; but they are all connected in my mind with my grief for my father--with the strange, powerful compassion I had for him, and some involuntary prescience of my own fate. For it was him I thought of, and never my mother, whom I had never seen, and whose gentle, patient temper was not so attractive to my disposition. No--I never thought he was to blame! I never paused to consider if it was himself who had brought this abiding shadow over his life. I only echoed his words in my heart, and clung to him, in secret, with a profound and passionate sympathy. Pity! I shuddered at the word. I no longer wondered at his haughty rejection of the slightest approach to it--for did not I myself share--exaggerate this very pride. This mournful tedious day went on, and its dreary business was accomplished: all our belongings were taken away from Cottiswoode, and Alice and another servant accompanied them to set our new house in order before we came. Just before she went away, at noon, when the autumn day was at its brightest, I found Alice cutting the roses from my favorite tree. I stood looking at her, as she took the pale faint flowers one by one, but neither of us spoke at first: at last I asked her, "why do you take them, Alice?" and I spoke so low, and felt so reverential that I think I must have anticipated her reply. I had to bend forward to her, to hear what she said. "They were your mother's," said Alice, "I decked her bride chamber with them, and her last bed. They are like what she was when trouble came." She had only left one rose upon the tree, a half blown rose, with dew still lying under its folded leaves, and she went away, leaving me looking at it. I felt reproved, I know not why, as if my young mother was crying to me for sympathy, and I would not give it. No! I went back hastily to the dreary half-emptied library where my father sat. My place was by him--this solitary man, who all his life had felt it rankling in his heart, that he was pitied where he should have been loved.