The decline of the West, Volume 1 : $b Form and actuality — John Shaqi
The decline of the West, Volume 1 : $b Form and actualitySpengler, Oswald
Philosophy
The decline of the West, Volume 1 : $b Form and actuality
Spengler, Oswald
Civilization -- History
As regards Classical history-writing, take Thucydides. The mastery of
this man lies in his truly Classical power of making alive and self-
explanatory the events of the _present_, and also in his possession of
the magnificently _practical outlook_ of the born statesman who has
himself been both general and administrator. In virtue of this quality
of _experience_ (which we unfortunately confuse with the historical
sense proper), his work confronts the merely learned and professional
historian as an inimitable model, and quite rightly so. But what is
absolutely hidden from Thucydides is perspective, the power of surveying
the history of centuries, that which for us is implicit in the very
conception of a historian. The fine pieces of Classical history-writing
are invariably those which set forth matters within the political
present of the writer, whereas for us it is the direct opposite, our
historical masterpieces without exception being those which deal with a
distant past. Thucydides would have broken down in handling even the
Persian Wars, let alone the general history of Greece, while that of
Egypt would have been utterly out of his reach. He, as well as Polybius
and Tacitus (who like him were practical politicians), loses his
sureness of eye from the moment when, in looking backwards, he
encounters motive forces in any form that is unknown in his practical
experience. For Polybius even the First Punic War, for Tacitus even the
reign of Augustus, are inexplicable. As for Thucydides, his lack of
historical feeling—in our sense of the phrase—is conclusively
demonstrated on the very first page of his book by the astounding
statement that before his time (about 400 B.C.) no events of importance
had occurred (oὐ μεγάλα γενέσθαι) in the world![4]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account