_Constitutional condition._—If a generalisation would be permissible
solely upon the cases in my own list, I should be inclined to think
that the patients were rather above than below the average in health.
Twenty-six out of the thirty-nine had passed threescore and ten when
they came under my notice, and with four exceptions all were in good
physical condition, and one (a woman with fairly well-marked contraction
in both hands) had reached the span of ninety-three years. In each case
careful inquiries were made with reference to the inheritance or past
or present existence of gout, rheumatism, and rheumatoid arthritis, and
the result, confirmed as far as possible by direct examination of the
patients, was altogether contrary to my preconceived notions on the
subject. Of the whole number, only one had suffered from gout, one from
rheumatic fever, three from rheumatoid arthritis (all in women, whose
Dupuytren’s disease was limited to slight palmar lesion), and six from
mild subacute or chronic rheumatism. A possible gouty inheritance was
traced in three cases. All were free from nervous disorders except two of
the women, who were subject to neuralgias of an ordinary kind, and one
(aged seventy-three) with a double contraction of thirty years’ standing,
who was suffering from hemiplegia of three years’ duration. No complaint
as to the digestive functions was made in any case.
The evidence brought forward by different observers with regard to
constitutional tendency appears to be extremely conflicting. Thus,
Dr. Keen, whose contribution is one of the most careful records we
possess, found no fewer than forty-two gouty patients out of forty-eight
cases; and Mr. Adams expresses his opinion that the disease is a
gouty thickening of the palmar fascia. Dr. Abbe of New York, on the
other hand, has noticed a remarkable frequency of nervous symptoms in
connection with Dupuytren’s contraction, and believes that the complaint
is of neuropathic origin, while other surgeons have in like manner
assigned to rheumatism, rheumatoid arthritis, alcoholism, and other
conditions an important causative relation with the disease. There
is, of course, no doubt that such widespread affections as gout and
rheumatism, neuroses and alcoholism are present in certain cases—it would
be strange were it not so; but it is noticeable that the writer who gives
a prominent place in the causation to any one of these conditions always
holds the claims of the rest in very low esteem; and it appears probable
that the associated constitutional tendencies noticed in the different
groups of cases depended rather upon the particular class or set from
which the observer drew his patients than upon any essential connection
between the local and internal affections. My own experience of the
disease has been based principally upon cases in hospitals, and hence the
remarkable absence in my series of the neurotic or gouty predispositions
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account