“Our mission is to turn out not worse men, but better men.”
THE TREATMENT OF THE MISDEMEANANT
[This excellent summary of the present correctional treatment of the
misdemeanant was read by Amos W Butler, chairman of the Committee on
Corrections, at the National Conference of Charities and Corrections
in Memphis, in May, 1914.]
Who knows how many persons are confined in local jails in the United
States? Who comprehends the magnitude of the problem involved? How many
appreciate its relation to the individual, to his family, to society?
The Bureau of the Census tells us that 452,055 persons were committed
to county and municipal prisons in 1910, under sentence or for
non-payment of fine. We call them misdemeanants. It is the name
ordinarily given one whose offense the law does not deem sufficiently
serious to warrant a State prison sentence. If the ratio of commitments
to the whole number received is the same throughout the United States
as in Indiana, it is probable that one and one-half million people
annually come under the influence of these local prisons.
We know that jails are the spoil of partisan politics. They are
maintained largely on the fee basis. Most of them were built without
any proper idea of the purpose they were intended to serve. As a rule
they are insanitary, they lack proper provision for separating the
sexes and there is no means of employment. Often they are crowded
beyond their capacity. There is little attempt to classify the
prisoners. They congregate in the corridors and the older and more
experienced in criminal ways instruct the others in vice, immorality
and crime. In how many such institutions are women not only waited upon
but searched by men?
The late Samuel J. Barrows once remarked: “Back in 1876 a committee of
the New York Legislature said: ‘There is no one source of crime more
operative in the multiplication of thieves and burglars than the common
jail’ and that statement still remains true of a large number of jails
throughout the country.”
Many of you have heard Dr. F. H. Wines’ scathing denunciation of
these institutions. Delegates to the International Prison Congress
who visited this country in 1910 declared our local jail system as
bad as it was centuries ago in Europe. “Every jail I saw ought to be
wiped off the face of the earth,” said Thomas Holmes, secretary of the
Howard Association of London, and this was the general verdict of these
distinguished prison officials and penologists. It was the idleness of
the prisoners, the lack of fresh air, the indiscriminate mingling, the
long-delayed trials that impressed them so unfavorably. “I asked two
colored men how long they would be in and they said they did not know;
that they had waited eleven days for a trial,” said Dr. Eugene Borel,
professor of law in the University of Geneva, Switzerland. “That is
a shocking travesty of justice. In Europe a prisoner gets a hearing
within twenty-four hours.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account