It is by no means universally accepted that children go through a phase
of separation from their parents and through the consequent
individuation. Most psychodynamic theories [especially Klein, Mahler]
are virtually constructed upon this foundation. The child is considered
to be merged with his parents until it differentiates itself (through
object-relations). But researchers like Daniel N. Stern dispute this
hypothesis. Based on many studies it appears that, as always, what
seems intuitively right is not necessarily right. In "The Interpersonal
World of the Infant: A View from Psychoanalysis and Developmental
Psychology" [New York, Basic Books - 1985], Stern seems to,
inadvertently, support Kohut by concluding that children possess selves
and are separate from their caregivers from the very start. In effect,
he says that the picture of the child, as depicted by psychodynamic
theories, is influenced by the way adults see children and childhood in
retrospect. Adult disorders (for instance, the pathological need to
merge) are attributed to children and to childhood.
This view is in stark contrast to the belief that children accept any
kind of parents (even abusive) because they depend on them for their
self-definition. Attachment to and dependence on significant others is
the result of the non-separateness of the child, go the classical
psychodynamic/object-relations theories. The self is a construct (in a
social context, some add), an assimilation of the oft-imitated and
idealised parents plus the internalisation of the way others perceive
the child in social interactions.
The self is, therefore, an internalised reflection, an imitation, a
series of internalised idealisations. This sounds close to pathological
narcissism. Perhaps it is really a matter of quantity rather than
quality.
D. Childhood Traumas and the Development of the Narcissistic
Personality
Traumas are inevitable. They are an inseparable part of life. But in
early childhood - especially in infancy (ages 0 to 4 years) they
acquire an ominous aura, an evil, irreversible meaning. No matter how
innocuous the event and the surrounding circumstances, the child's
vivid imagination is likely to embed it in the framework of a highly
idiosyncratic horror story.
Parents sometimes have to go away due to medical or economic
conditions. They may be too preoccupied to stay attuned at all times to
the child's emotional needs. The family unit itself may be
disintegrating with looming divorce or separation. The values of the
parent may stand in radical contrast to those of society.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account