The early history of the HebrewsSayce, A. H. (Archibald Henry)
History
The early history of the Hebrews
Sayce, A. H. (Archibald Henry)
Bible. Old Testament -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.; Jews -- History -- To 953 B.C.
An influential school of modern critics has come to conclusions which
are difficult to reconcile with this external testimony. Instead of the
Pentateuch it offers us a Hexateuch, the Book of Joshua being added to
those of Moses, and of the origin and growth of this Hexateuch it
professes to be able to give a minute and mathematically exact account.
Very little, if any of it, we are told, goes back to the period of
Moses, the larger part of the work having been composed or compiled in
the age of the Exile. It is true, the theories of criticism have changed
from time to time; what was formerly held, for instance, to be the
oldest portion of the Hexateuch being now regarded as the latest; but
each generation of critics has been equally confident that its own
literary analysis was mathematically correct. At present the
hypothetical scheme most in favour is as follows.
The earliest part of the Hexateuch, at all events in its existing form,
is a document distinguished by the use of the name Yahveh, and sometimes
therefore termed Yahvistic or Jehovistic, but more usually designated by
the symbol J. The Yahvist is supposed to have been a Jew who made use of
older materials, and lived in the ninth century B.C. His work begins
with ‘the second’ account of the Creation, in the middle of the fourth
verse of the second chapter of Genesis, and the last trace of it is to
be found in the story of the death and burial of Moses at the end of
Deuteronomy. His style is said to be naïve and lively, and his
conceptions of the Deity grossly anthropomorphic.
Next in order to the Yahvist comes the Second Elohist (symbolised by the
letter E), whose title is derived from the period, not very far distant,
in the history of criticism, when what is now known as the Priestly Code
was assigned to a First Elohist. The Elohist is characterised by the use
of the word Elohim, ‘God,’ rather than Yahveh, and the critics have
discovered in him a native of the northern kingdom. To him belong the
‘Ten Words’ which represent the original form of the Ten Commandments,
as well as the history of Joseph. He is said to have written with a
certain theological tendency, to which is due his predilection for
introducing dreams and angels into his narrative. His date is ascribed
to the eighth century B.C., and the combination of his narrative with
that of the Yahvist (J.E.) produced a composite work to which the name
of Prophetic or Pre-Deuteronomic Redaction has been applied. The
Redactor endeavoured to reconcile the contradictions between the two
narratives by various harmonistic expedients; his success was not great,
and the nineteenth century critic accordingly believes himself able not
only to separate the two original documents, but to point out the
additions of the Redactor as well.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account