The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
The writings of De Tocqueville and Beaumont, the delegates sent out by
France to study the cellular plan in America, had a wide influence in
restraining that excessive zeal for aiming at the moral or religious
reform of prisoners, which had inspired the Quakers of Pennsylvania in
their crusade against the abuses of the old system. The words of De
Tocqueville are worth quoting, as they called back the minds of men
at a time when such a warning was greatly needed, to a just and wise
appreciation of the function and purpose of punishment, and corrected
a tendency which is always asserting itself, to exaggerate the
necessity for moral and spiritual reform, at the expense of the other
essential attributes of punishment. He says, "I say it boldly: if the
penitentiary system has no other purpose than reform, the lawgiver must
abandon the system, not because it is not admirable, but because it
is too rarely attained. The moral reform of the individual is a great
thing for the religious man, but not for the statesman: a political
institution does not exist for the individual, but for the mass. Moral
reform is then only an accident of the system. Its value is in the
habit of order, work, separation, education, obedience to inflexible
rule. These have a profound moral value. If a man is not made honest,
he contracts honest habits: he was a useless person, he now knows how
to work: if he is not more virtuous, he is at least more reasonable: he
has the morality of self-interest, if not of honour."
MM. De Tocqueville and Beaumont had been commissioned by the French
Government in 1831 to visit the United States, and to report on the
comparative advantages of the Auburn and Pennsylvania systems. They
were followed in 1837 by M. Demetz, the famous founder of the Colony
of Mettray. It was due to the influence of these men, aided by the
writings of MM. Lucas and Bérenger in France, and of Ducpetiaux in
Belgium, that a remarkable impulse was given in Western Europe to the
adoption of the cellular system. Two International Congresses were held
at Frankfort in 1846, which declared in favour of the separate system.
It was to this period of keen interest in the question of prison reform
that in England we owe the model prison at Pentonville, 1842, the
Prison of Louvain in Belgium, and a large number of cellular prisons
built in France, Switzerland, Prussia, Sweden, Norway and Denmark. We
have here the beginning of the later International movement, which
afterwards found expression in the International Prison Commission-a
formal body of experts nominated by most of the leading States of the
World, whose periodical meetings in different centres since the London
Congress of 1872 are recognized as a great civilizing influence in
all that relates to the treatment of prisoners, the construction of
Prisons, and the revision of penal law.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account