The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
The first International Congresses--known generally as 'Prison'
Congresses, were concerned more with 'Prison' than with penal law,
with visits to penal establishments, and with comparisons of Prison
systems. The _régime pénitentiaire_ was the principal pre-occupation,
but the subjects of discussion soon outgrew the original limits. The
sphere of inquiry gradually broadened. The prison régime is only the
expression of the penal law, which itself again is only the expression
of the public sentiment or opinion, which is the final arbiter in
deciding the methods to be followed in maintaining the rights of the
community against those who threaten its peace and security. Succeeding
Congresses, therefore, as was to be anticipated, composed, as they
were, not only of Prison officials and experts in prison management,
but of persons from all countries, distinguished in law, medicine, and
science, claimed for themselves a larger field and a more ambitious
title. _La 'Science' pénitentiaire_ is declared to be the new scope
and title of the work. It is an all-embracing phrase, and, from the
necessities of the case, of ambiguous meaning. It includes both
practical knowledge of administration, and the knowledge by which
Science, in its strict sense, can inform and instruct in dealing
with the problem of crime, and of criminal man. To these must be
added Social Science, and all implied by that wide term. The reaction
that became manifest at the close of the last century was against
what is called the "classical" conception of crime and punishment.
Professor G. Vidal, the eminent author of 'Droit Criminel et la science
pénitentiaire' has shown how rigid and mechanical, under the influence
of the French penal code, the administration of criminal justice had
become. The accused was simply a '_type abstrait_' a "_mannequin
vivant sur lequel le juge colle un numéro du code pénal_." A reaction
against this abstract conception of crime came in the early 'eighties
from a school of Criminologists known as the Italian School, of which
the chief was Lombroso. Theories of the _criminel-né_--i.e., a human
being fore-doomed to crime by atavistic propensity, and distinguishable
physical stigmata, or '_tares physiologiques_'--created considerable
sensation at the time, and it cannot be denied that, though refuted by
later enquiry, they exercised a profound influence in Europe, and gave
a direct impulse to the scientific study of the _causes_ predisposing
to criminal acts. This study has since become the principal
pre-occupation in all countries of those interested in what, by a
misnomer, is spoken of generally as Prison Reform. The phrase remains,
but it refers no longer to questions concerning the construction and
management of prisons, the comparative merits of the cellular or
associated plan, forms and methods of prison industries, staff and
discipline. The Prison Reformer of to-day has adopted from Continental
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account