The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
A CRIMINOLOGICAL INQUIRY IN ENGLISH PRISONS.
An attempt has lately been made in this country to apply scientific
method to the study of criminal man. A vast amount of data relating
to the personal condition, social estate, and penal histories of
"convicts" (_i.e._, men sentenced to penal servitude for three
years and upwards) has been co-ordinated and amplified by physical
measurements, by details of personal and family history, and by
description of physical and mental qualities. An examination in respect
of all or some of these points of 3,000 men, taken without selection
from those undergoing penal servitude in English Convict Prisons, has
formed the basis of this inquiry.
Of this large number of sets of observations, which were made by
the Medical Officers of the Convict Prisons, Dr. Goring contributed
considerably more than half, and to him was entrusted the onerous
task of tabulating the material of the whole. With the assistance and
advice of Professor Karl Pearson, Dr. Goring was enabled to carry out
this work which he has achieved with remarkable patience and ability.
The main intention of this investigation at the outset was to obtain
accurate information whereby the many hypotheses advanced by different
schools of criminology, and especially the Italian Schools, might
be confirmed or refuted. But the scope of the work grew, perhaps
inevitably, beyond its original purpose, and now includes not only an
analysis of the physical and mental condition of convicts, but also
many data for speculations on very difficult and contentious questions
as to the relative influence of "heredity," "environment," &c., on the
genesis of 'criminals' generally.
Dr. Goring's complete and elaborate Report, entitled "The English
Convict--a Statistical Study," has been published by the Government
in an official Blue-Book. It appears now as Dr. Goring's own work,
carried out by a special method, and the conclusions arrived at are his
own. I do not propose to attempt to criticise either his method or his
conclusions, being aware that such an attempt would involve discussion
of some matters on which there is much difference of scientific opinion.
This work is, as far as I know, the first essay made in any country to
arrive at results on criminology by the strict application of what is
known as the biometrical method of statistical treatment of recorded
observations. Whatever its merits or demerits may be, it at least marks
an epoch in the history of criminological studies. In the pages which
follow, I endeavour to present in a more simple and popular form, and,
as far as possible, in his own words, an abstract of Dr. Goring's
views, and of the results to which his general inquiry has led him.
Students of Criminology must turn to the original volume itself for a
detailed exposition of the whole case which the author so ably presents.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account