The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
The postulate of the "Positive" School, with which the name of the
celebrated Professor Lombroso will always be associated, is that crime
or criminality is a morbid or pathological state akin to disease,
or, in other words, an abnormal state, due to certain physical
or mental defects, made manifest by certain stigmata or "_tares
physiologiques_"--the result either of inherited defect or reversion
to atavistic type, or in short, that there is "a criminal type"
_i.e._, a race of beings predestined to criminal acts, against whom
any system of punishment would be futile, as by nature such beings
would not be amenable to the deterrent influences of penal law. This
theory--of which the logical result would be either elimination of the
unfit, or the translation into the province of medicine of all legal
procedure--has failed to command general assent or approval. Like all
half-truths, it is extremely dangerous, for it is, of course, the
fact that morbid conditions are associated, to a certain degree, with
crime, and, like all sensational dogmas, based on untested observation,
it affected the public imagination, prone to believe that the criminal
is a sort of "bogey-man"--the stealthy enemy of peaceful persons, ever
ready to leap in the dark. This uneasy feeling encouraged the idea
that the criminal was a class by himself--an abnormal being, the child
of darkness, without pity and without shame, and with the predatory
instincts of a wild beast. Thus gradually the common belief has taken
root that there is a criminal type, and that it is persons of this
particular brand or species who commit crime, and go to Prison. This
belief is what Dr. Goring calls the great "superstition" of the day,
which stands in the way of Prison reform, which darkens counsel in
dealing with crime, which renders rehabilitation difficult, and which
stifles and discourages the zeal of the philanthropist, to whom the
"criminal" is a man of like passions with himself, and amenable to the
same influences; and not predestined to crime and anti-social conduct,
from which no human effort could save him.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account