The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
The question of the existence of a criminal type is regarded as
essentially anthropometrical, _i.e._, it can only be solved by the
statistical analysis of a large series of measurements. Anthropometry
has, of course, been used as an instrument by criminologists, but its
strict application demands more than the crude contrast of mean values
which is the most that has been hitherto attempted: in addition to
the means, it insists that probable errors should be also calculated
and recorded; that a measure of the variability of each series of
measurements should be obtained; and that, in every case, effects upon
measurement due to differentiation in age, stature, intelligence,
&c., of the contrasted populations under measurement should be also
estimated and allowed for.
Having, by means of a comparison with regard to thirty-seven
representative physical attributes of criminals, distinguished (1)
by their conviction for different orders of crime, _e.g._, thefts,
assault, arson, sexual offences, and frauds, (2) by their frequency of
reconviction, and (3) by the length of their imprisonment, established
the conclusion that criminals are not physically differentiated
because they are criminals, but because of difference in age, stature,
intelligence, &c., our author proceeds to a comparison between
statistics of criminals, as a class, and of the non-criminal public.
The absence of any comparative data with regard to many of the physical
characters of the law-abiding classes is, of course, fatal to any
precise demonstration, but a comparison of the head-length, -breadth,
-height, -index, and -circumference in convicts is made with similar
statistics of a set of undergraduates of Oxford, Cambridge, and
Aberdeen Universities, and of the London University College Staff,
with the result that prison inmates, as a whole, approximate closer
in head-measurement to the Universities generally than do students of
different Universities conform with each other in this regard, and
that from a knowledge only of an undergraduate's cephalic measurement,
a better judgment could be given as to whether he were studying at an
English or Scottish University, than a prediction could be made whether
he would eventually become a University Professor, or a convicted felon.
Similar comparison with the general Hospital population and with
soldiers (118 non-commissioned officers, and men of the Royal
Engineers) establishes a similar conclusion that, so far as
head-measurements are concerned, the criminal, and the hospital
patient, and the soldier cannot be differentiated.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account