The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
Next, comparison with some seventeenth century skulls, recently
discovered while excavations were being made in Whitechapel, leads to
the interesting conclusion that there is a close agreement between
correlation values obtained from measurements of English skulls
300 years old, and those calculated from the cephalic-diameters of
English convicts alive to-day. And a detailed comparative analysis of
head-length and -breadth statistics brings against a current theory,
respecting the anomalous conformation of the criminal's head, the
following fact: that amongst 200 criminals, the head of only one will
be genuinely anomalous--a proportion less than has been found amongst
Scottish insane people, and probably much the same as would be found in
any section of the law-abiding healthy community.
Comparison with respect to hair and eye colour, nose conformation,
deafness, left-handedness, tattooing, of such data as are available,
illustrates the absence of any marked peculiarity in the case
of criminals, and, lastly, a comparison of the head-contours of
800 convicts with those of 118 Royal Engineers, according to a
plan invented by Professor Pearson for comparing skull-contours,
demonstrates with great precision that, so far from criminals as
a class being differentiated or stigmatized by low and receding
foreheads, by projecting occiputs, by asymmetry, and by sugar-loaf,
dome-shaped, and other peculiar forms of heads, the agreement between
the contrasted types is so remarkable, and the differences so trifling,
that at least in this respect no ground can be said to exist for
the popular belief that criminal tendency can be inferred from the
shape of a man's head. From all these comparisons, pursued strictly
according to the biometric method of which I have only attempted to
give the outline, Dr. Goring draws his conclusion that "no evidence has
emerged confirming the existence of a physical criminal type, such as
Lombroso and his disciples have described. The data show that physical
differences exist between different kinds of criminals, precisely as
they exist between different kinds of law-abiding people. But, when
allowance is made for a certain range of probable variation, and when
they are reduced to a common standard of age, stature, intelligence,
class, &c., these differences tend entirely to disappear. The results
nowhere confirm the evidence, nor justify the allegations, of criminal
anthropologists. They challenge their evidence at almost every point.
In fact, both with regard to measurements and the presence of physical
anomalies in criminals, the statistics present a startling conformity
with similar statistics of the law-abiding classes. The final
conclusion we are bound to accept until further evidence, in the train
of long series of statistics, may compel us to reject or to modify an
apparent certainty--our inevitable conclusion must be that _there is no
such thing as a physical criminal type_."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account