The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
It is also held by Dr. Goring that there is no such thing as a "mental
criminal type." It is not denied that marked unlikeness of mental
characters exists between criminal groups, as it does between different
sections of the law-abiding community; but the point emphasised is
that this unlikeness is associated not with a differentiation in
criminal tendency, but with the criminal's differentiation in general
intelligence or mental capacity, which, according to the nature of
his crime, varies enormously: _e.g._, the percentage of actual mental
defectives convicted of stack-firing is 53, of rape 16, of stealing 11,
of manslaughter 5, whereas amongst persons convicted of embezzlement,
forgery, and other forms of fraud, the percentage is practically zero.
The recent Commission on the Care and Control of the Feeble-minded,
from an enumeration of defectives in sixteen representative districts
of the British Isles, estimated that ·46 per cent. of the whole
population of England and Wales are mentally defective; a similar
enumeration in prisons, casual wards, shelters, etc., revealed
10·28 per cent. of mental defects. Dr. Goring contends that it is
clear from this that criminals, as well as showing wide differences
amongst themselves, are also, as a class, highly differentiated in
mental capacity from the law-abiding classes. Mental defectives, it
is argued, unlike the insane and pathological imbeciles, are not a
special class of human beings, and they are chiefly distinguished from
other normal persons by their low level of general intelligence. The
term mental deficiency, as applied to convicts, as well as connoting
a mind of inferior capacity, in many cases implies also an unbalanced
mind, _i.e._, a mind whose equilibrium is easily disturbed by the
preponderance of extreme degrees of objectionable and dangerous
qualities, such as impulsiveness, excitability, passionate temper, &c.
These qualities are held to be not "morbid" but "natural," being shared
in some degree by persons of all mental grades. The measure of general
intelligence among criminals bears also a striking relation to their
occupational class. Thus, if we examine, say, 1,000 cases of conviction
for crime, we should find that the percentage of mentally defective
criminals varied from 6 to 35, accordingly as the offender belonged
to the professional, commercial, artizan, or labouring class,--the
actual percentages for all crime in each class being 6, 15, 26, and 35,
respectively. Probably, in the opinion of Dr. Goring, the chief source
of the high relationship between weak-mindedness and crime resides in
the fact that the criminal thing, which we call "criminality," and
which leads to the perpetration of many, if not most, anti-social
offences to-day, is not _inherent wickedness_, but natural stupidity.
The striking characteristic of 90 per cent. of offences is their
incredible stupidity, and, moreover, it is probable that the commonly
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account