The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
But although no physical type peculiar to criminals can be
demonstrated, certain physical differences in criminals have emerged,
and it is in the examination of these differences that Dr. Goring
attempts to establish a theory of criminality more simple and
reasonable than that which refers them to the presence of a definite
criminal type. From a comparison of the stature and weight of the
general population, published in 1882 by the British Association for
the Advancement of Science, he shows that, (apart from differences
due to class differentiation,) in physique, as measured by stature
and weight, criminals, with the exception of those convicted of
fraud, are markedly differentiated from the non-criminal sections
of the community. This physical inferiority, however, must not be
associated with any condition of degeneracy, atavism, or other defect,
mental or physical, originating spontaneously, but all the evidence
points to the truth of the theory that these bodily conditions are
"selective factors" determining, to some extent, conviction for crime.
It may be imagined that as good physique determines occupation, so a
bad physique predisposes to a criminal career. It also facilitates
arrest by the Police, and apprehensions are considerably fewer than
offences committed. It is, too, generally observed that persons of
good physique are less irascible and prone to violence, and the case
of the incendiary would show that a weakly man has recourse to a mean
act from motives of revenge, not being capable of an act requiring
physical force. "Fraudulents," it is true, are not selected for
crime, for they resemble, in weight and stature, the law-abiding
public; but they are an exceptional case, which, while destructive
of a theory of degeneracy, is not necessarily inimical to the theory
that physique selects crime. Dr. Goring does not deny that there is a
possibility that this physical inferiority may tend to become an inbred
characteristic of the criminal classes, the convicted fathers having
sons who inherit their diminutive stature, and thus, in course of time,
an inbred differentiation of the criminal classes might result. That
this may be so is illustrated by statistics, which show that industrial
and reformatory school children are consistently on the average one
inch shorter in stature, and several pounds less in weight, than any
other class of school-children of the same age in the United Kingdom.
Nothing more than this can be conceded to the Lombrosian School. The
only fact at the basis of criminal anthropology is that thieves,
and burglars, and incendiaries (_i.e._, about 90 per cent. of all
criminals) are markedly differentiated from the general population in
stature and body-weight. There is no other scientific foundation than
this for the extravagant doctrines of the "Positive" School.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account