The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
law, and social hygiene. While firmly maintaining the system of human
rights unimpaired, and while not failing in the protection of the
State from any attack made on that system by persons, individually
or collectively, let us exhaust every means for saving the potential
offender from succumbing inevitably, in the absence of prophylactic
methods, to the temptations to commit anti-social acts, which from
causes mental, physical, or social he is unable to resist. This is
the meaning of the 'individualization of punishment'--it is quite
consistent with a firm administration of penal justice, but it destroys
for ever the old classical idea of the 'abstract type of criminal.' In
other words, justice demands that the old formula of 'Imprisonment with
or without hard labour' indiscriminately applied, shall no longer be
held to satisfy all her claims.
The reaction against this so-called '_dosimétrie pénale_' i.e.,
the abstract conception of crime and the mechanical application of
punishment 'according to code' is a growing force. It is marked
in the United States of America by the universal adoption of the
'Indeterminate sentence,' and on the Continent of Europe by various
degrees for conditional conviction and liberation which find their
place in the latest penal codes. In England and America, Probation:
in France and Belgium, the '_sursis à l'exécution de la peine_'--all
mark the reluctance to resort to fixed penalties when Justice can be
satisfied by other means. England, I believe, stands alone in its
adoption of the system of Preventive Detention--one of the most notable
reforms of recent years for dealing with the Habitual Criminal. The
success of the system, so far as it has gone, goes far to justify
belief in the virtue of Indetermination of sentence. Public opinion
may not be ripe for this yet, as applied to ordinary crime, but the
principle which the system of Preventive Detention illustrates,
_viz_:--the careful observation of the history, character, and
prospects on discharge by an Advisory Committee on the spot, with a
view to the grant of conditional freedom, furnishes in a different
sphere an interesting example of the value of 'individualization.' The
strict condition of release is that a man places himself under the
care and supervision _not of the Police_, but of a State Association,
organized and subsidized by the Government, but entirely controlled
by a body of unofficial workers, who keep him under strict but kindly
supervision, provide him with employment and lodgings, but unfailingly
report him to the Authorities if he fails to observe any one of the
conditions on which freedom has been granted. The singular success of
this system applied to the worst and most inveterate criminals, each
of whom has been found by a Jury to belong to the habitual criminal
class, has naturally induced the opinion which is gaining ground,
that similar methods might, with advantage, be used in dealing with
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account