The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
Of physical damage we need not speak, for it must, I think, be conceded
that the medical care of prisoners in this country is as exact, and
patient, and considerate, as can be secured by an able, humane, and
untiring medical staff.
With moral damage it is different. The most sanguine would hardly
expect that, even with the most approved methods, the '_flétrissure_'
of punishment can be entirely avoided: the blow to pride and
self-respect, and of the respect of one's fellow creatures, must
constitute a damage which, if not irreparable, must be heavy and
even lasting. A humane administration will try and mitigate this
inevitable incident of all punishment. Its first and primary function
must be, of course, to secure obedience, discipline, order, and the
habit of industry. These things alone have a great moral value.
Many cruelties have been enacted in the past in the name of prison
discipline--solitude, darkness, chains, floggings, tread wheels and
cranks, even until a comparatively recent period, were regarded as
the essential accessories of punishment. In studying the history of
punishment, we cannot fail to be struck by the singular inventiveness
of the human mind in designing forms of suffering for those who
broke the law--crucifixion, mutilation, stoning, drowning, torture.
It was not until the folly of unprofitable and cruel punishment had
been illustrated, as in this country, by its failure to correct, or
prevent, or until the certainty of punishment was recognized as the
real deterrent for crime, that the penal system was rationalized, and
by a slow process, due to a progressive widening of the circle of
humanity, to what M. Tarde describes as "_la propagation ambiante des
exemples_," the civilized races of the world laid down the sharp and
cruel instruments by which alone it had been believed that society
could be avenged, and justice secured. It came slowly to be recognized,
not only as a religious, but as a political truth, that the worst
criminal possessed 'reversionary rights of humanity,' and that it was
only by respecting these that there existed the chance, and the hope,
that a man might be reformed by punishment, and not thrown back again
into the world with only one burning desire to avenge himself for the
cruelties which society had indicted upon him. This is the meaning of
the Platonic maxim that the purpose of punishment is "to make men good."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account