The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
"Those who advocate remission, make supervision an essential element
in their system, as necessary not only for the security of the public,
but also for the protection of the convict himself when first set free
and exposed anew to temptation. But it may be questioned first, whether
supervision is practicable; secondly, whether, if practicable, it is
not more mischievous than beneficial. There can be little doubt that by
change of name, and change of locality, which, as we have just seen,
is largely resorted to for this purpose, holders of Tickets-of-Leave
can without much difficulty elude the vigilance of the police; and
no adequate means have been suggested for satisfactorily overcoming
this difficulty. But a far more serious objection arises from the
fact that, at least in this country, any supervision by the police,
or other officer appointed for the purpose, would be fatal to the
convict's chance of employment, on which his continuing in the right
course, if so disposed, so materially depends. Police supervision is
incompatible with the concealment of the man's antecedents, while, in
the great majority of instances, the well-doing of the convict must
depend on his secret being kept. Few masters would employ a man who
was known to be a convicted felon, and an equal obstacle would be
found in the disinclination of other labourers to be associated with
one thus degraded. It would seem, therefore, that if remission is to
be continued, it would be better that it should not be attended by
any attempt at supervision, the beneficial effects of which, from the
difficulty of carrying it out, are doubtful, while its mischievous
tendency, so far as relates to the welfare of the convict, is apparent.
It would seem to be better to leave the liberated convict to take
his chance of finding employment and making his way as he can, than
to fetter him with a clog which may prevent the possibility of honest
exertion."
It was in consequence of the Report of the Commission that in 1864 an
Act was passed raising the minimum sentence of Penal Servitude from
three to five years. The Act also authorized any two or more Justices
of the Peace to exercise powers of corporal punishment for offences
against Prison discipline, hitherto vested exclusively in one of
the Directors, the Commission of 1863 having expressed the opinion
that acts of violence committed by convicts were not punished with
sufficient promptitude or severity. This measure also enacted the
principle that a convict on licence should report periodically to the
Police of the district in which he should reside, and any failure to
comply with the conditions imposed in the licence might result in its
forfeiture, and in the re-committal of the holder to Prison.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account