The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
"It is often asked, "What is the value of these Congresses?" It must
not be supposed that an Englishman, going to hear discussions on penal
subjects in a foreign country, where the laws, habits, and character
of the people are entirely different, is going to bring back new ideas
of Prison administration, which he will be able at once to apply,
with advantage, in his own country; nor must it be supposed that he
is going to carry with him instructions and opinions on these matters
which other nations will readily adopt. With a pardonable pride in
his national institutions, he is disposed to think that his Prison
system is the best in the world; but when he goes abroad he must not
be surprised to hear the same claim raised by other countries. He will
find that where the English system is not known or is misunderstood,
it is but little appreciated. There is a general idea that our
punitive methods are harsh, if not barbarous. Legends circulate as to
the terrors of the "_fouet_," the ingenious torture of "_la roue_,"
and the grinding tyranny of "_travaux forcés_." It is not surprising
that even an intelligent foreigner fails to grasp the distinction
between a sentence of "hard labour" and one of "penal servitude:" so
misleading are our terms. At the recent Congress, the Head of the
Russian Prisons asked me what is the minimum time for which a sentence
of "hard labour" could be imposed, thinking that it was something in
its duration and severity comparable to the "_katorga_" of his own
country. When I explained that it might be inflicted for one day only,
he turned to his Secretary with a smile, saying, "How little do we
understand the English system!" There is a minority, and I hope an
increasing one, who understand and appreciate the efforts that have
been made of late years to improve the conditions of the treatment of
crime in this country."
The comparatively few foreigners who had a personal acquaintance with
our Institutions did not conceal their admiration for the order,
method, discipline, and exactness which characterize our methods of
dealing with crime; but, generally speaking, these legendary ideas
prevailed.
The shadow of transportation, of the dark days of penal servitude, and
of grievous floggings, hindered a true conception of English methods.
I looked forward to the London Congress as the occasion to dispel these
illusions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account