The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)Hobbes, Thomas
Philosophy
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)
Hobbes, Thomas
Philosophy, English -- 17th century
But what shall we answer to the words in Ecclesiasticus: _Say not thou,
it is through the Lord I fell away; say not thou, he hath caused me to
err_. If it had not been, _say not thou_, but “think not thou,” I should
have answered that Ecclesiasticus is Apocrypha, and merely human
authority. But it is very true that such words as these are not to be
said; first, because St. Paul forbids it: _Shall the thing formed_,
saith he, _say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me so?_ Yet
true it is, that he did so make him. Secondly, because we ought to
attribute nothing to God but what we conceive to be honourable, and we
judge nothing honourable but what we count so amongst ourselves; and
because accusation of man is not honourable, therefore such words are
not to be used concerning God Almighty. And for the same cause it is not
lawful to say that any action can be done, which God hath purposed shall
not be done; for it is a token of want of the power to hinder it.
Therefore neither of them is to be said, though one of them must needs
be true. Thus you see how disputing of God’s nature which is
incomprehensible, driveth men upon one of these two rocks. And this was
the cause I was unwilling to have my answer to the Bishop’s doctrine of
liberty published.
And thus much for comparison of our two opinions with the Scriptures;
which whether it favour more his or mine, I leave to be judged by the
reader. And now I come to compare them again by _the inconveniences
which may be thought to follow them_.
First, the bishop says, that this very persuasion, that all things come
to pass by _necessity_, is able to overthrow all societies and
commonwealths in the world. The laws, saith he, are unjust which
prohibit that which a man cannot possibly shun.
Secondly, that it maketh superfluous and foolish all consultations,
arts, arms, books, instruments, teachers, and medicines, and which is
worst, piety and all other acts of devotion. For if the event be
necessary, it will come to pass whatsoever we do, and whether we sleep
or wake.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account