The Essentials of American Constitutional LawThorpe, Francis Newton
History
The Essentials of American Constitutional Law
Thorpe, Francis Newton
Constitutional law -- United States
In placing the obligation of contracts under the protection of the
Constitution, its framers looked to the essentials of the contract
more than to the forms and modes of proceeding by which it was
to be carried out into execution; annulling State legislation
which impaired the obligation, it was left to the States to
prescribe and shape the remedy to enforce it. The obligation of a
contract consists in its binding force on the party who makes it.
This depends on the laws in existence when it is made; these are
necessarily referred to in all contracts and forming a part of them
as the measure of the obligation to perform them by the one party,
and the right acquired by the other. There can be no other standard
by which to ascertain the extent of either, than that which the
terms of the contract indicate according to their settled legal
meaning; when it becomes consummated, the law defines the duty
and the right, compels one party to perform the thing contracted
for, and gives the other a right to enforce the performance by the
remedies then in force. If any subsequent law affect to diminish
the duty, or to impair the right, it necessarily bears on the
obligation of the contract, in favor of one party, to the injury
of the other; hence, any law which, in its operation, amounts to
a denial, or obstruction, of the rights accruing by a contract,
though professing to act only on the remedy, is directly obnoxious
to the prohibition of the Constitution.[200]
78. The prohibition of legislation impairing the obligation of
contracts does not extend to the United States as it does to the
States. Thus in the Legal Tender Cases[201] and in sundry bankruptcy
cases.[202] the Supreme Court has decided that the exercise of the
power of Congress “does not depend upon the incidental effect of its
exercise on contracts, but on the existence of the power itself.” This
means that the United States possesses a police power, _salus populi
suprema lex_, in exercise of which at the discretion of Congress, the
obligation of contracts must yield to the higher obligation of the
general welfare.[203]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account