The Ethics of Medical Homicide and MutilationO'Malley, Austin
Religion
The Ethics of Medical Homicide and Mutilation
O'Malley, Austin
Medical ethics
Whether the fetus is animated at conception or some time later,
there is no foundation whatever for the notion that the female is
quickened later than the male. As was said before, Aristotle held
that the human male fetus is animated at the fortieth day, the female
at the ninetieth day, and the old moralists accepted his statement.
At the fortieth day, however, no one can differentiate sex unless
the microscope is used, and this particular use of the microscope is
altogether modern--the knowledge requisite for such use was not in
existence sixty years ago. At the twentieth day, with the microscope
and a stained specimen, a biologist can recognize whether the
primordial ova are present or absent and thus determine sex. Only at
the eighty-fourth day can sex now be differentiated without the aid
of the microscope, but then the embryo must be dissected: nothing can
be told from its external appearance. Sex can first be distinguished
by the external appearance only at about the one hundred and twelfth
day, the end of the fourth month of gestation. Therefore when
Aristotle said the male fetus is animated at the fortieth day, and
the female at the eightieth or ninetieth day, he was romancing.
The question, then, narrows to this: Is any human fetus animated
immediately at conception, or from forty to eighty days after
conception? The reason given by the followers of Aristotle for
deferring animation is that the vital principle requires organs in
the receptive material, but the embryo in the early stages, they say,
lacks these organs. This notion, however, as to the lack of organs
is altogether erroneous, and the rational soul enters the embryo
in the oval stage, immediately after the pronuclei unite: there is
organization in that stage of human life sufficient to receive the
substantial form or soul. We do not know how long after insemination
the pronuclei unite, but the proposition here is that as soon as
they unite the human soul enters. Fecundation usually occurs after a
menstruation, but not necessarily so; the spermatozoön may live in
the tube for seventeen days awaiting the ovum.
The human body is made up of billions of microscopic living cells,
all of which are derived by fission and differentiation from the
two original single germ-cells, the ovum and the spermatozoön.
Some nerve-cells have long processes running along the white
fibres through the entire length of the body, but they cannot be
differentiated except by the microscope. In the body are also
various liquids which are not cellular, as water, saliva, tears,
urine, blood and lymph plasma, and the gastric, intestinal, and
glandular juices, and these are secreted or excreted by the somatic
cells. The cells assimilate nutritive material carried to them by
the blood, excrete refuse substances, secrete glandular products,
and are the media for all human operations below certain acts of the
intellect.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account