_Mr. William Jennings Bryan_: An expert cannot be permitted
to come in here and try to defeat the enforcement of a law by
testifying that it isn’t a bad law and it isn’t—I mean a bad
doctrine—no matter how these people phrase the doctrine—no
matter how they eulogize it. This is not the place to prove
that the law ought never to have been passed. The place to
prove that, or teach that, was to the state legislature....
The people of this state passed this law, the people of the
state knew what they were doing when they passed the law, and
they knew the dangers of the doctrine—that they did not want it
taught to their children, and my friends, it isn’t—your honor,
it isn’t proper to bring experts in here and try to defeat the
purpose of the people of this state by trying to show that
this thing they denounce and outlaw is a beautiful thing that
everybody ought to believe in.... It is this doctrine that
gives us Nietzsche, the only great author who tried to carry
this to its logical conclusion, and we have the testimony of
my distinguished friend from Chicago in his speech in the Loeb
and Leopold case that 50,000 volumes have been written about
Nietzsche, and he is the greatest philosopher in the last
hundred years, and have him pleading that because Leopold read
Nietzsche and adopted Nietzsche’s philosophy of the super-man,
that he is not responsible for the taking of human life. We
have the doctrine—I should not characterize it as I should
like to characterize it—the doctrine that the universities
that had it taught, and the professors who taught it, are much
more responsible for the crime that Leopold committed than
Leopold himself. That is the doctrine, my friends, that they
have tried to bring into existence, they commence in the high
schools with their foundation of evolutionary theory, and we
have the word of the distinguished lawyer that this is more
read than any other in a hundred years, and the statement of
that distinguished man that the teachings of Nietzsche made
Leopold a murderer.... (_Mr. Bryan reading from a book by
Darrow_) “I will guarantee that you can go to the University of
Chicago today—into its big library and find over 1,000 volumes
of Nietzsche, and I am sure I speak moderately. If this boy
is to blame for this, where did he get it? Is there any blame
attached because somebody took Nietzsche’s philosophy seriously
and fashioned his life on it? And there is no question in
this case but what it is true. Then who is to blame? The
university would be more to blame than he is. The scholars of
the world would be more to blame than he is. The publishers
of the world—and Nietzsche’s books are published by one of
the biggest publishers in the world—are more to blame than he
is. Your honor, it is hardly fair to hang a 19-year-old boy
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account