If the state is correct in its insistence, it is immaterial,
so far as the results of this case are concerned, as to
which theory is true; because it is within the province of
the legislative branch, and not the judicial branch of the
government to pass upon the policy of a statute; and the policy
of this statute having been passed upon by that department of
the government, this court is not further concerned as to its
policy; but is interested only in its proper interpretation
and, if valid, its enforcement.... Therefore the court is
content to sustain the motion of the attorney-general to
exclude expert testimony.
THE PROSECUTION
_Mr. Stewart_ (during Mr. Darrow’s cross-examination of Mr.
Bryan): I want to interpose another objection. What is the
purpose of this examination?
_Mr. Bryan_: The purpose is to cast ridicule upon everybody
who believes in the Bible, and I am perfectly willing that the
world shall know that these gentlemen have no other purpose
than ridiculing every Christian who believes in the Bible.
THE DEFENSE
_Mr. Darrow_: We have the purpose of preventing bigots and
ignoramuses from controlling the education of the United
States, and you know it, and that is all.
Statements of Noted Scientists as Filed into Record by Defense
Counsel
_Charles H. Judd, Director of School of Education, University
of Chicago_: It will be impossible, in my judgment, in the
state university, as well as in the normal schools, to teach
adequately psychology or the science of education without
making constant reference to all the facts of mental
development which are included in the general doctrine of
evolution.... Whatever may be the constitutional rights of
legislatures to prescribe the general course of study of public
schools it will, in my judgment, be a serious national disaster
if the attempt is successful to determine the details to be
taught in the schools through the vote of legislatures rather
than as a result of scientific investigation.
_Jacob G. Lipman, Dean of the College of Agriculture, State
University of New Jersey_: With these facts and interpretations
of organic evolution left out, the agricultural colleges and
experimental stations could not render effective service to our
great agricultural industry.
_Wilbur A. Nelson, State Geologist of Tennessee_: It,
therefore, appears that it would be impossible to study or
teach geology in Tennessee or elsewhere, without using the
theory of evolution.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account