Second, it is a matter of curious interest that a warning against
literal reading occurs at an early stage of the _Phaedrus_. Here in the
opening pages, appearing as if to set the key of the theme, comes an
allusion to the myth of Boreas and Oreithyia. On the very spot where the
dialogue begins, Boreas is said to have carried off the maiden. Does
Socrates believe that this tale is really true? Or is he in favor of a
scientific explanation of what the myth alleges? Athens had scientific
experts, and the scientific explanation was that the north wind had
pushed her off some rocks where she was playing with a companion. In this
way the poetical story is provided with a factual basis. The answer of
Socrates is that many tales are open to this kind of rationalization,
but that the result is tedious and actually irrelevant. It is irrelevant
because our chief concern is with the nature of the man, and it is
beside the point to probe into such matters while we are yet ignorant
of ourselves. The scientific criticism of Greek mythology, which may
be likened to the scientific criticism of the myths of the Bible in
our own day, produces at best “a boorish sort of wisdom (ἀγροίκῳ τινὶ
σοφίᾳ).” It is a limitation to suppose that the truth of the story
lies in its historicity. The “boorish sort of wisdom” seeks to supplant
poetic allegation with fact, just as an archaeologist might look for the
foundations of the Garden of Eden. But while this sort of search goes
on the truth flies off, on wings of imagination, and is not recoverable
until the searcher attains a higher level of pursuit. Socrates is
satisfied with the parable, and we infer from numerous other passages
that he believed that some things are best told by parable and some
perhaps discoverable only by parable. Real investigation goes forward
with the help of analogy. “Freud without Sophocles is unthinkable,” a
modern writer has said.[3]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account