Conscious actions depend directly on the will, and they have a close
connexion with instinctive actions in as far as these also can be
controlled by the will, that is, can be set a-going or inhibited, and
also, on the other hand, in as far as purely voluntary actions may
become instinctive through frequent repetition. The first case is
illustrated, for instance, when the suckling of a child at the mother's
breast is continued into the second year of life, as not infrequently
happens in the southern countries of Europe. Such a child knows exactly
why it wants the breast, and its action is a conscious one, while the
newborn child seeks about with the mouth instinctively, and when it has
found what it sought performs the somewhat complex sucking movements
automatically. The second case is illustrated, when, for instance, we
have made a habit of winding up a watch on going to bed, and do it when
we happen to change our clothes through the day, although it is then
purposeless and would have been omitted if the action had required
a conscious effort of will. One can often observe on oneself in how
short a time a conscious action may become instinctive. I once sent my
keyless watch to a watchmaker for repairs, and received from him for
the time an ordinary watch, which had to be wound with a key, which
key I kept for safety in my purse. At the end of eight days I got
back my own watch, and on undressing the first night I found myself
'instinctively' taking my purse from my pocket in order to get the key,
which, as I very well knew, I no longer needed. And that a long series
of complex movements, originally performed only consciously, may be
gone through instinctively, is shown by the fact that pieces of music
which have been learnt by heart can often be played without mistake
from beginning to end while the player is thinking of quite other
things. The complex instinctive actions of animals are performed in
quite a similar manner.
There is thus no sharp boundary line between reflex and instinctive
actions, nor between instinctive and conscious actions, but one passes
over into the other, and the thought suggests itself, that in the
phyletic development also transitions from one kind of action to the
other must have taken place. As long as one believes the Lamarckian
principle to be really operative one can suppose that actions, which
were originally dependent on the will, when they were often repeated,
became instinctive, or, in other words, that instincts, many of them at
least, are inherited habits.
I shall endeavour to show later on that this assumption, plausible as
it seems at first sight, cannot be correct; but in the meantime I must
confine myself to saying that there are a great number of instincts
which must be referred to the process of selection, and that the rest
can be similarly interpreted in their essentials at least.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account