The same is true of all cells differentiated for particular functions;
every new kind of glandular, muscular, or nerve cell, such as have
arisen a thousandfold in the course of phylogeny, can only have
resulted from a struggle between individuals which turned on the
possession of the best cells of a particular kind, _not from a struggle
between the cells themselves_, since these would gain no advantage
from serving the organism, as a whole, better than others of their
kind. In regard to the sex-cells we might admit, in addition to
personal selection, the possibility of an internal struggle between the
sperm-cells or egg-cells of the same individual, inasmuch as each of
these cells is the primordium of a new individual, and as those better
adapted for reproduction might transmit their better quality to these
new individuals. I will not here enter into my reasons for regarding
this idea as erroneous, for in any case this interpretation would not
apply to any other kind of cells. If, for instance, it were a question
of the transformation of an ordinary mucus or salivary gland into a
poison gland, it would not matter in the least to the individual cell
whether it yielded a harmless or a poisonous secretion; but individuals
with many poisonous cells would have an advantage in the struggle for
existence.
I agree so far with Plate when he refers the differentiation of
the tissues entirely to personal selection, but not in his further
conclusion that histonal selection does not exist. The ground-plan
of the architectural structure of the organ depends upon personal
selection, but the realization of the plan in particular cases is
not predetermined down to the minutest details, but is regulated by
histonal selection, and is thus to a certain extent an adaptation to
local conditions of stimulus. The direction, strength, and size of
every single bone lamella is not predetermined from the germ, but only
the occurrence and nature of bone-cells and bone lamellæ in general.
The direction and the strength which these bone lamellæ may assume
depends on the local conditions of strain and pressure which affect the
cell-mass, as is shown very clearly by the spongiosa of an obliquely
healed bone, which we have already described.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account